Hanssens Lise G M, Detollenaere Jens D J, Van Pottelberge Amelie, Baert Stijn, Willems Sara J T
Department of Family Medicine and Primary Health Care, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
Department of Sociology, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
Health Soc Care Community. 2017 Mar;25(2):641-651. doi: 10.1111/hsc.12353. Epub 2016 Apr 25.
Recent figures show that discrimination in healthcare is still persistent in the European Union. Research has confirmed these results but focused mainly on the outcomes of perceived discrimination. Studies that take into account socioeconomic determinants of discrimination limit themselves to either ethnicity, income or education. This article explores the influence of several socioeconomic indicators (e.g. gender, age, income, education and ethnicity) on perceived discrimination in 30 European countries. Data from the QUALICOPC study were used. These data were collected between October 2011 and December 2013 in the participating countries. In total, 7183 GPs (general practitioners) and 61932 patients participated in the study, which had an average response rate of 74.1%. Data collection was co-ordinated by NIVEL (Dutch Institute for Research of Health Care). Bivariate binomial logistic regressions were used to estimate the impact of each socioeconomic indicator on perceived discrimination. Multivariate logistic regressions were used to estimate the unique effect of each indicator. Results indicate that in Europe, overall 7% of the respondents felt discriminated, ranging between 1.4% and 12.8% at the country level. With regard to socioeconomic determinants in perceived discrimination, income and age are both important indicators, with lower income groups and younger people having a higher chance to feel discriminated. In addition, we find significant influences of education, gender, age and ethnicity in several countries. In most countries, higher educated people, older people, women and the indigenous population appeared to feel less discriminated. In conclusion, perceived discrimination in healthcare is reported in almost all European countries, but there is large variation between European countries. A high prevalence of perceived discrimination within a country also does not imply a correlation between socioeconomic indicators and perceived discrimination.
最近的数据显示,欧盟医疗保健领域的歧视现象依然存在。研究证实了这些结果,但主要集中在感知到的歧视的后果上。考虑到歧视的社会经济决定因素的研究,要么局限于种族、收入或教育其中之一。本文探讨了几个社会经济指标(如性别、年龄、收入、教育和种族)对30个欧洲国家感知到的歧视的影响。使用了QUALICOPC研究的数据。这些数据于2011年10月至2013年12月在参与国收集。共有7183名全科医生和61932名患者参与了该研究,平均回复率为74.1%。数据收集由荷兰卫生保健研究所(NIVEL)协调。采用双变量二项逻辑回归来估计每个社会经济指标对感知到的歧视的影响。采用多变量逻辑回归来估计每个指标的独特效应。结果表明,在欧洲,总体上7%的受访者感到受到歧视,在国家层面上,这一比例在1.4%至12.8%之间。关于感知到的歧视中的社会经济决定因素,收入和年龄都是重要指标,低收入群体和年轻人感到受到歧视的可能性更高。此外,我们发现在几个国家,教育、性别、年龄和种族都有显著影响。在大多数国家,受教育程度较高的人、老年人、女性和原住民似乎感到受到的歧视较少。总之,几乎所有欧洲国家都报告了医疗保健领域存在感知到的歧视,但欧洲国家之间存在很大差异。一个国家内感知到的歧视的高发生率也并不意味着社会经济指标与感知到的歧视之间存在关联。