Hollister Jeffrey W, Kreakie Betty J
Office of Research and Development, National Health and Environmental Effects Research Laboratory, Atlantic Ecology Division, US Environmental Protection Agency, Narragansett, RI, USA.
F1000Res. 2016 Feb 9;5:151. doi: 10.12688/f1000research.7955.2. eCollection 2016.
Cyanobacteria harmful algal blooms (cHABs) are associated with a wide range of adverse health effects that stem mostly from the presence of cyanotoxins. To help protect against these impacts, several health advisory levels have been set for some toxins. In particular, one of the more common toxins, microcystin, has several advisory levels set for drinking water and recreational use. However, compared to other water quality measures, field measurements of microcystin are not commonly available due to cost and advanced understanding required to interpret results. Addressing these issues will take time and resources. Thus, there is utility in finding indicators of microcystin that are already widely available, can be estimated quickly and in situ, and used as a first defense against high levels of microcystin. Chlorophyll a is commonly measured, can be estimated in situ, and has been shown to be positively associated with microcystin. In this paper, we use this association to provide estimates of chlorophyll a concentrations that are indicative of a higher probability of exceeding select health advisory concentrations for microcystin. Using the 2007 National Lakes Assessment and a conditional probability approach, we identify chlorophyll a concentrations that are more likely than not to be associated with an exceedance of a microcystin health advisory level. We look at the recent US EPA health advisories for drinking water as well as the World Health Organization levels for drinking water and recreational use and identify a range of chlorophyll a thresholds. A 50% chance of exceeding one of the specific advisory microcystin concentrations of 0.3, 1, 1.6, and 2 μg/L is associated with chlorophyll a concentration thresholds of 23, 68, 84, and 104 μg/L, respectively. When managing for these various microcystin levels, exceeding these reported chlorophyll a concentrations should be a trigger for further testing and possible management action.
蓝藻有害藻华(cHABs)与一系列广泛的不良健康影响相关,这些影响主要源于蓝藻毒素的存在。为了帮助预防这些影响,已针对某些毒素设定了多个健康咨询水平。特别是,较常见的毒素之一微囊藻毒素,已针对饮用水和娱乐用水设定了多个咨询水平。然而,与其他水质指标相比,由于成本以及解读结果所需的专业知识,微囊藻毒素的现场测量并不常见。解决这些问题需要时间和资源。因此,找到已广泛可得、可快速原位估算且能作为抵御高浓度微囊藻毒素的第一道防线的微囊藻毒素指标具有实用价值。叶绿素a是常用的测量指标,可原位估算,并且已被证明与微囊藻毒素呈正相关。在本文中,我们利用这种关联来提供叶绿素a浓度的估算值,这些估算值表明超过微囊藻毒素特定健康咨询浓度的可能性更高。利用2007年全国湖泊评估和条件概率方法,我们确定了叶绿素a浓度,这些浓度很可能与微囊藻毒素健康咨询水平超标相关。我们查看了美国环境保护局(US EPA)最近的饮用水健康咨询以及世界卫生组织(WHO)的饮用水和娱乐用水标准,并确定了一系列叶绿素a阈值。分别超过0.3、1、1.6和2μg/L这几个特定微囊藻毒素咨询浓度之一的50%可能性,与叶绿素a浓度阈值23、68、84和104μg/L相关。在管理这些不同的微囊藻毒素水平时,超过这些报告的叶绿素a浓度应触发进一步检测和可能的管理行动。