Holm Anne Guro Vreim, Lurås Hilde, Randsborg Per-Henrik
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Akershus University Hospital, 1478 Lørenskog, Norway.
Health Services Research Centre, Akershus University Hospital, 1478 Lørenskog, Norway; Institute of Clinical Medicine, Campus Ahus, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway.
Injury. 2016 Jul;47(7):1410-3. doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2016.04.007. Epub 2016 Apr 28.
Paediatric fractures are common and frequently followed-up. The aim of this study is to quantify the private costs for the affected families, as well as the costs for society due to paediatric fracture clinic follow-up appointments.
295 paired parent and surgeon questionnaire regarding the cost related to a scheduled follow-up appointment for an upper limb fracture in children aged 6-13 years were collected prospectively over 7 months. In addition, the medical appropriateness of the appointment and whether or not the control changed the management of the fracture was investigated.
The direct cost of attending a paediatric upper limb fracture clinic was estimated to €48.5 while the cost for society due to productivity loss was €78.4 per consultation. In 89.2% of the cases the surgeons found the appointment necessary, it was deemed unnecessary or inconclusive in 10.6%. The treatment plan was altered in 6.8%, and an extra follow up was scheduled in 5.8%. Fractures of the clavicle were most often regarded as unnecessary to follow up clinically or radiologically by the surgeons.
The direct cost for the affected families and the costs for society due to productivity loss of paediatric fracture follow-up appointments are noticeable. Although most patients and surgeons deem these controls as valuable, they lead to a change in treatment plan in only 12.6% of the cases. A stringent management protocol can safely reduce the number of clinical and radiographical follow-ups.
儿童骨折很常见且经常需要随访。本研究的目的是量化受影响家庭的私人成本,以及儿童骨折门诊随访预约给社会带来的成本。
前瞻性地收集了295对家长和外科医生关于6至13岁儿童上肢骨折预定随访预约相关成本的问卷,为期7个月。此外,还调查了预约的医学合理性以及复查是否改变了骨折的治疗方案。
儿童上肢骨折门诊就诊的直接成本估计为48.5欧元,每次会诊因生产力损失给社会带来的成本为78.4欧元。在89.2%的病例中,外科医生认为预约是必要的,10.6%的病例被认为不必要或无定论。6.8%的病例治疗方案发生了改变,5.8%的病例安排了额外的随访。锁骨骨折最常被外科医生认为在临床或放射学上无需随访。
儿童骨折随访预约给受影响家庭带来的直接成本以及因生产力损失给社会带来的成本是显著的。尽管大多数患者和外科医生认为这些复查很有价值,但仅12.6%的病例导致了治疗方案的改变。严格的管理方案可以安全地减少临床和影像学随访的次数。