Laakso Ilkka, Tanaka Satoshi, Mikkonen Marko, Koyama Soichiro, Sadato Norihiro, Hirata Akimasa
Department of Electrical Engineering and Automation, Aalto University, Espoo, Finland; Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Nagoya Institute of Technology, Nagoya, Japan.
Laboratory of Psychology, Hamamatsu University School of Medicine, Shizuoka, Japan.
Neuroimage. 2016 Aug 15;137:140-151. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2016.05.032. Epub 2016 May 14.
The electric field produced in the brain is the main physical agent of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS). Inter-subject variations in the electric fields may help to explain the variability in the effects of tDCS. Here, we use multiple-subject analysis to study the strength and variability of the group-level electric fields in the standard brain space. Personalized anatomically-accurate models of 62 subjects were constructed from T1- and T2-weighted MRI. The finite-element method was used to computationally estimate the individual electric fields, which were registered to the standard space using surface based registration. Motor cortical and frontal tDCS were modelled for 16 electrode montages. For each electrode montage, the group-level electric fields had a consistent strength and direction in several brain regions, which could also be located at some distance from the electrodes. In other regions, the electric fields were more variable, and thus more likely to produce variable effects in each individual. Both the anode and cathode locations affected the group-level electric fields, both directly under the electrodes and elsewhere. For motor cortical tDCS, the electric fields could be controlled at the group level by moving the electrodes. However, for frontal tDCS, the group-level electric fields were more variable, and the electrode locations had only minor effects on the group average fields. Our results reveal the electric fields and their variability at the group level in the standard brain space, providing insights into the mechanisms of tDCS for plasticity induction. The data are useful for planning, analysing and interpreting tDCS studies.
大脑中产生的电场是经颅直流电刺激(tDCS)的主要物理作用因素。个体间电场的差异可能有助于解释tDCS效果的变异性。在此,我们使用多主体分析来研究标准脑空间中群体水平电场的强度和变异性。从T1加权和T2加权磁共振成像构建了62名受试者的个性化解剖精确模型。使用有限元方法通过计算估计个体电场,并使用基于表面的配准将其配准到标准空间。针对16种电极组合模式对运动皮层和额叶tDCS进行了建模。对于每种电极组合模式,群体水平的电场在几个脑区具有一致的强度和方向,这些脑区也可能位于距电极一定距离处。在其他区域,电场更具变异性,因此在每个个体中更有可能产生可变的效果。阳极和阴极位置均会影响群体水平的电场,无论是在电极正下方还是其他位置。对于运动皮层tDCS,可以通过移动电极在群体水平上控制电场。然而,对于额叶tDCS,群体水平的电场更具变异性,电极位置对群体平均电场的影响较小。我们的结果揭示了标准脑空间中群体水平的电场及其变异性,为tDCS诱导可塑性的机制提供了见解。这些数据对于规划、分析和解释tDCS研究很有用。