Kaur Gurvinder, Koshy Jacob, Thomas Satish, Kapoor Harpreet, Zachariah Jiju George, Bedi Sahiba
Associate Professor, Department of Ophthalmology, Christian Medical College , Ludhiana, Punjab, India .
Professor, Department of Ophthalmology, Christian Medical College , Ludhiana, Punjab, India .
J Clin Diagn Res. 2016 Apr;10(4):NC09-14. doi: 10.7860/JCDR/2016/18939.7628. Epub 2016 Apr 1.
Early detection and treatment of vision problems in children is imperative to meet the challenges of childhood blindness. Considering the problems of inequitable distribution of trained manpower and limited access of quality eye care services to majority of our population, innovative community based strategies like 'Teachers training in vision screening' need to be developed for effective utilization of the available human resources.
To evaluate the effectiveness of introducing teachers as the first level vision screeners.
Teacher training programs were conducted for school teachers to educate them about childhood ocular disorders and the importance of their early detection. Teachers from government and semi-government schools located in Ludhiana were given training in vision screening. These teachers then conducted vision screening of children in their schools. Subsequently an ophthalmology team visited these schools for re-evaluation of children identified with low vision. Refraction was performed for all children identified with refractive errors and spectacles were prescribed. Children requiring further evaluation were referred to the base hospital. The project was done in two phases. True positives, false positives, true negatives and false negatives were calculated for evaluation.
In phase 1, teachers from 166 schools underwent training in vision screening. The teachers screened 30,205 children and reported eye problems in 4523 (14.97%) children. Subsequently, the ophthalmology team examined 4150 children and confirmed eye problems in 2137 children. Thus, the teachers were able to correctly identify eye problems (true positives) in 47.25% children. Also, only 13.69% children had to be examined by the ophthalmology team, thus reducing their work load. Similarly, in phase 2, 46.22% children were correctly identified to have eye problems (true positives) by the teachers. By random sampling, 95.65% children were correctly identified as normal (true negatives) by the teachers.
Considering the high true negative rates and reasonably good true positive rates and the wider coverage provided by the program, vision screening in schools by teachers is an effective method of identifying children with low vision. This strategy is also valuable in reducing the workload of the eye care staff.
早期发现并治疗儿童视力问题对于应对儿童失明的挑战至关重要。鉴于训练有素的人力分配不均以及我国大多数人口获得优质眼保健服务的机会有限,需要制定像“视力筛查教师培训”这样基于社区的创新策略,以有效利用现有人力资源。
评估引入教师作为一级视力筛查人员的有效性。
为学校教师开展教师培训项目,使其了解儿童眼部疾病及其早期发现的重要性。对位于卢迪亚纳的政府和半政府学校的教师进行视力筛查培训。这些教师随后在各自学校对儿童进行视力筛查。随后,一个眼科团队前往这些学校对被确定为视力低下的儿童进行重新评估。对所有被确定有屈光不正的儿童进行验光并开具眼镜处方。需要进一步评估的儿童被转诊至基地医院。该项目分两个阶段进行。计算真阳性、假阳性、真阴性和假阴性以进行评估。
在第一阶段,166所学校的教师接受了视力筛查培训。教师们筛查了30205名儿童,并报告4523名(14.97%)儿童有眼部问题。随后,眼科团队检查了4150名儿童,确认其中2137名儿童有眼部问题。因此,教师能够正确识别47.25%儿童的眼部问题(真阳性)。此外,只有13.69%的儿童需要眼科团队检查,从而减轻了他们的工作量。同样,在第二阶段,教师正确识别出46.22%的儿童有眼部问题(真阳性)。通过随机抽样,教师正确识别出95.65%的儿童为正常(真阴性)。
鉴于高真阴性率、合理的真阳性率以及该项目提供的更广泛覆盖范围,教师在学校进行视力筛查是识别视力低下儿童的有效方法。该策略在减轻眼保健工作人员的工作量方面也很有价值。