Yuan Dong-Mei, Li Qian, Zhang Qin, Xiao Xin-Wu, Yao Yan-Wen, Zhang Yan, Lv Yan-Ling, Liu Hong-Bin, Lv Tang-Feng, Song Yong
Department of Respiratory Medicine, Jinling Hospital, Nanjing University School of Medicine, Nanjing, China E-mail :
Asian Pac J Cancer Prev. 2016;17(4):1661-75. doi: 10.7314/apjcp.2016.17.4.1661.
Can addition of neurokinin-1 receptor antagonists (NK1-RAs) be considered as an ideal strategy for the prevention of chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting (CINV)? Researchers differ on this question.
Electronic databases were searched for randomized control trials (RCTs) that evaluated the effectiveness and safety of NK1-RAs in preventing CINV. The primary end point was complete response (CR) in the acute, delayed, and overall phases after chemotherapy. Subgroup analyses evaluated the types of NK1-RAs, routines of administration, types of malignancies, regimens used in combination with NK1-RAs, and age of patients included in the studies. The incidences of different types of adverse events were also extracted to estimate the safety of NK1-RAs.
A total of 38 RCTs involving 13,923 patients were identified. The CR rate of patients receiving NK-RAs was significantly higher than patients in the control groups during overall phase (70.8% vs 56.0%, <0.001), acute phase (85.1% vs 79.6%, <0.001), and delayed phase (71.4% vs 58.2%, <0.001). There were three studies including patients of children or adolescents, the CR rate was also significantly higher in the treatment group (overall phase: OR=2.807, <0.001; acute phase: OR=2.863, P =0.012; delayed phase: OR=2.417, <0.001). For all the other outcomes, patients in the NK1-RAs groups showed improvements compared to the control groups (incidence of nausea: 45.2% vs 45.9%, <0.001; occurrence of vomiting: 22.6% vs 38.9%, <0.001; usage of rescue drugs: 23.5% vs 34.1%, <0.001). The pooled side effects from NK1-RAs did not significantly differ from previous reports and the toxicity rates in patients less than eighteen years old also did not diff between the two groups (P=0.497). However, we found that constipation and insomnia were more common in the patients of control groups, whereas diarrhea and hiccups were more frequently detected in patients receiving NK1-RAs.
NK1-RAs improved the CR rate of CINV. They are effective for both adults and children. The use of NK1-RAs might be associated with the appearance of diarrhea and hiccups, while decreasing the possibility of constipation and insomnia.
添加神经激肽-1受体拮抗剂(NK1-RAs)能否被视为预防化疗引起的恶心和呕吐(CINV)的理想策略?研究人员对此问题存在分歧。
检索电子数据库,查找评估NK1-RAs预防CINV有效性和安全性的随机对照试验(RCTs)。主要终点是化疗后急性、延迟和总体阶段的完全缓解(CR)。亚组分析评估了NK1-RAs的类型、给药方案、恶性肿瘤类型、与NK1-RAs联合使用的方案以及研究中纳入患者的年龄。还提取了不同类型不良事件的发生率,以评估NK1-RAs的安全性。
共确定了38项涉及13923名患者的RCTs。在总体阶段(70.8%对56.0%,<0.001)、急性期(85.1%对79.6%,<0.001)和延迟期(71.4%对58.2%,<0.001),接受NK-RAs治疗的患者的CR率显著高于对照组。有三项研究纳入了儿童或青少年患者,治疗组的CR率也显著更高(总体阶段:OR=2.807,<0.001;急性期:OR=2.863,P =0.012;延迟期:OR=2.417,<0.001)。对于所有其他结果,与对照组相比,NK1-RAs组的患者有改善(恶心发生率:45.2%对45.9%,<0.001;呕吐发生率:22.6%对38.9%,<0.001;救援药物使用情况:23.5%对34.1%,<0.001)。NK1-RAs的合并副作用与先前报告无显著差异,两组中小于18岁患者的毒性率也无差异(P=0.497)。然而,我们发现便秘和失眠在对照组患者中更常见,而腹泻和打嗝在接受NK1-RAs治疗的患者中更频繁出现。
NK1-RAs提高了CINV的CR率。它们对成人和儿童均有效。使用NK1-RAs可能与腹泻和打嗝的出现有关,同时降低便秘和失眠的可能性。