Rhodes F, Wolitski R
J Am Coll Health. 1989 May;37(6):266-71. doi: 10.1080/07448481.1989.9937493.
The effectiveness of four commercial videotape presentations in changing AIDS knowledge and attitudes among 584 college students was evaluated in a pre-post design with control group and follow-up. AIDS knowledge and attitudes were measured prior to, immediately after, and 4 to 6 weeks following presentation of the informational videotapes. In addition, subjects rated each videotape on several specific dimensions, including overall quality. The effects of age, sex, prior exposure to AIDS information, and presence v absence of post-presentation discussion were measured as covariates. In general, there was a significant immediate increase in AIDS knowledge attributable to all four videotapes (p less than .001). These gains persisted until follow-up, with no erosion for three of the four tapes. With the exception of perceived effectiveness of AIDS prevention methods (p less than .001), attitudes toward AIDS showed no change as a result of exposure to any of the videotapes (p greater than .05). Viewer ratings showed two of the videotapes to be superior in terms of perceived overall quality (p less than .05). There were also differences in ratings of videos on other dimensions. Among the covariates, there was no relationship at time of follow-up between post-presentation discussion v no discussion and either knowledge gain or attitude change. Sex was related to one attitude component, with women perceiving the AIDS epidemic as more severe than men (p less than .001).
采用带有对照组和随访的前后测设计,评估了4部商业录像带对584名大学生艾滋病知识和态度的改变效果。在播放信息性录像带之前、之后即刻以及之后4至6周,对艾滋病知识和态度进行了测量。此外,受试者还从包括整体质量在内的几个特定维度对每部录像带进行了评分。将年龄、性别、之前接触艾滋病信息的情况以及播放录像带后是否进行讨论作为协变量进行测量。总体而言,所有4部录像带均使艾滋病知识有显著的即刻增加(p小于0.001)。这些知识增益一直持续到随访时,4部录像带中有3部的增益没有衰减。除了对艾滋病预防方法的感知有效性(p小于0.001)外,接触任何一部录像带后,对艾滋病的态度均未显示出变化(p大于0.05)。观众评分显示,就感知到的整体质量而言,其中2部录像带更胜一筹(p小于0.05)。在其他维度上,录像带的评分也存在差异。在协变量中,播放录像带后进行讨论与未进行讨论,在随访时与知识增益或态度改变之间均无关联。性别与一个态度成分相关,女性比男性更认为艾滋病流行情况严重(p小于0.001)。