Sale J E M, Ashe M C, Beaton D, Bogoch E, Frankel L
Musculoskeletal Health and Outcomes Research, Li Ka Shing Knowledge Institute, St. Michael's Hospital, 30 Bond Street, Toronto, ON, M5B 1W8, Canada.
Institute of Health Policy, Management and Evaluation, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Osteoporos Int. 2016 Oct;27(10):3113-9. doi: 10.1007/s00198-016-3641-4. Epub 2016 May 27.
In our qualitative study, men with fragility fractures described their spouses as playing an integral role in their health behaviours. Men also described taking risks, preferring not to dwell on the meaning of the fracture and/or their bone health. Communication strategies specific to men about bone health should be developed.
We examined men's experiences and behaviours regarding bone health after a fragility fracture.
We conducted a secondary analysis of five qualitative studies. In each primary study, male and female participants were interviewed for 1-2 h and asked to describe recommendations they had received for bone health and what they were doing about those recommendations. Maintaining the phenomenological approach of the primary studies, the transcripts of all male participants were re-analyzed to highlight experiences and behaviours particular to men.
Twenty-two men (50-88 years old) were identified. Sixteen lived with a wife, male partner, or family member and the remaining participants lived alone. Participants had sustained hip fractures (n = 7), wrist fractures (n = 5), vertebral fractures (n = 2) and fractures at other locations (n = 8). Fourteen were taking antiresorptive medication at the time of the interview. In general, men with a wife/female partner described these women as playing an integral role in their health behaviours, such as removing tripping hazards and organizing their medication regimen. While participants described giving up activities due to their bone health, they also described taking risks such as drinking too much alcohol and climbing ladders or deliberately refusing to adhere to bone health recommendations. Finally, men did not dwell on the meaning of the fracture and/or their bone health.
Behaviours consistent with those shown in other studies on men were described by our sample. We recommend that future research address these findings in more detail so that communication strategies specific to men about bone health be developed.
在我们的定性研究中,患有脆性骨折的男性表示,他们的配偶在其健康行为中发挥着不可或缺的作用。男性还描述了自己会冒险,不愿过多思考骨折的意义和/或自身骨骼健康状况。应制定针对男性的骨骼健康沟通策略。
我们研究了男性在发生脆性骨折后的骨骼健康经历和行为。
我们对五项定性研究进行了二次分析。在每项原始研究中,对男性和女性参与者进行了1至2小时的访谈,询问他们收到的关于骨骼健康的建议以及针对这些建议所采取的行动。保持原始研究的现象学方法,对所有男性参与者的访谈记录进行重新分析,以突出男性特有的经历和行为。
共确定了22名男性(年龄在50至88岁之间)。其中16人与妻子、男性伴侣或家庭成员同住,其余参与者独自生活。参与者发生过髋部骨折(n = 7)、腕部骨折(n = 5)、椎体骨折(n = 2)以及其他部位骨折(n = 8)。14人在接受访谈时正在服用抗吸收药物。总体而言,有妻子/女性伴侣的男性表示,这些女性在他们的健康行为中发挥着不可或缺的作用,比如清除绊倒隐患并安排他们的用药方案。虽然参与者表示由于骨骼健康问题而放弃了一些活动,但他们也描述了自己会冒险,如饮酒过量、爬梯子,或故意拒绝遵循骨骼健康建议。最后,男性不会过多思考骨折的意义和/或自身骨骼健康状况。
我们的样本描述了与其他关于男性的研究中所显示的行为一致的行为。我们建议未来的研究更详细地探讨这些发现,以便制定针对男性的骨骼健康沟通策略。