Carotenuto F, Tsikaridze N, Rook L, Lordkipanidze D, Longo Laura, Condemi Silvana, Raia P
Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra, dell'Ambiente e delle Risorse, Università degli Studi di Napoli "Federico II", Italy.
Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra, Università degli studi di Firenze, Italy; Georgian National Museum, Tbilisi, Georgia.
J Hum Evol. 2016 Jun;95:1-12. doi: 10.1016/j.jhevol.2016.02.005. Epub 2016 Mar 29.
The dispersal of Homo erectus out of Africa at some 1.9 million years ago is one of the most important, crucial, and yet controversial events in human evolution. Current opinions about this episode expose the contrast between those who see H. erectus as a highly social, cooperative species seeking out new ecological opportunities to exploit, and those preferring a passive, climate driven explanation for such an event. By using geostatistics techniques and probabilistic models, we characterised the ecological context of H. erectus dispersal, from its East African origin to the colonization of Eurasia, taking into account both the presence of other large mammals and the physical characteristics of the landscape as potential factors. Our model indicated that H. erectus followed almost passively the large herbivore fauna during its dispersal. In Africa, the dispersal was statistically associated with the presence of large freshwater bodies (Rift Valley Lakes). In Eurasia, the presence of H. erectus was associated with the occurrence of geological outcrops likely yielding unconsolidated flint. During the early phase of dispersal, our model indicated that H. erectus actively avoided areas densely populated by large carnivores. This pattern weakened as H. erectus dispersed over Europe, possibly because of the decreasing presence of carnivores there plus the later acquisition of Acheulean technology. During this later phase, H. erectus was associated with limestone and shaley marl, and seems to have been selecting for high-elevation sites. While our results do not directly contradict the idea that H. erectus may have been an active hunter, they clearly point to the fact that predator avoidance may have conditioned its long-distance diffusion as it moved outside Africa. The modelled dispersal route suggests that H. erectus remained preferentially associated with low/middle latitude (i.e., comparatively warm) sites throughout its colonization history.
约190万年前直立人走出非洲是人类进化过程中最重要、最关键但也最具争议的事件之一。目前对于这一事件的观点揭示了两种看法之间的差异:一方认为直立人是高度社会化、善于合作的物种,积极寻求新的生态机会加以利用;另一方则倾向于用被动的、受气候驱动的解释来说明这一事件。通过运用地质统计学技术和概率模型,我们描绘了直立人从东非起源到殖民欧亚大陆这一扩散过程的生态背景,将其他大型哺乳动物的存在以及地貌的物理特征作为潜在因素加以考虑。我们的模型表明,直立人在扩散过程中几乎是被动地追随着大型食草动物群落。在非洲,这种扩散在统计学上与大型淡水水体(裂谷湖)的存在相关。在欧亚大陆,直立人的出现与可能产出未固结燧石的地质露头的出现有关。在扩散的早期阶段,我们的模型表明直立人会主动避开大型食肉动物密集分布的区域。随着直立人在欧洲扩散,这种模式逐渐减弱,这可能是因为那里食肉动物的数量减少,以及后来阿舍利技术的获得。在这一后期阶段,直立人与石灰岩和页岩质泥灰岩有关,似乎一直在选择高海拔地区。虽然我们的结果并没有直接反驳直立人可能是积极猎手的观点,但它们清楚地表明,在其迁出非洲的过程中,躲避捕食者可能对其远距离扩散起到了制约作用。模拟的扩散路线表明,直立人在其整个殖民历史中始终优先与低/中纬度(即相对温暖)的地区相关联。