Rishworth Andrea, Bisung Elijah, Luginaah Isaac
Department of Geography and Environmental Management, University of Waterloo, 200 University Ave W., Waterloo, ON, Canada N2L 3G1.
Department of Geography and Environmental Management, University of Waterloo, 200 University Ave W., Waterloo, ON, Canada N2L 3G1.
Women Birth. 2016 Dec;29(6):e119-e125. doi: 10.1016/j.wombi.2016.05.004. Epub 2016 Jun 2.
While caesarean sections in developing contexts act as a marker for access to skilled care, little is known about the health outcomes of caesarean sections. With calls for a more in depth understanding of women's perceptions of this procedure in resource poor settings, this paper explores women's perceptions and experiences of caesarean birth in the context of Ghana's Maternal Exemption Policy of the National Health Insurance Scheme in the Upper West Region.
A qualitative study using 10 focus group discussions and 30 in depth interviews of mothers and pregnant women were conducted. The results were thematically analysed.
Drawing on theories of feminist geography and embodiment, the results suggest most women perceive caesarean section birth as highly problematic, acting as a long term disease, which hinders their ability to engage in economic activities and care for their children. In the context of the Maternal Exemption Policy, caesarean section birth restricts a woman's ability to secure further health insurance for themselves and newborn child, leaving long term access to health care uncertain. Findings also suggest long term repercussions of caesarean sections may go beyond the physical health of the mother and child to include other socio-cultural and contextual challenges.
Accordingly, caesarean sections position women in a multifaceted situation of vulnerability. This underscores the need for context appropriate maternal health programmes in developing countries.
在发展中环境下,剖宫产是获得熟练护理的一个标志,但对于剖宫产的健康结果却知之甚少。随着人们呼吁更深入地了解资源匮乏地区妇女对这一手术的看法,本文探讨了在加纳上西部地区国家健康保险计划的孕产妇豁免政策背景下,妇女对剖宫产分娩的看法和经历。
开展了一项定性研究,进行了10次焦点小组讨论,并对母亲和孕妇进行了30次深入访谈。对结果进行了主题分析。
借鉴女性主义地理学和身体化理论,结果表明大多数妇女认为剖宫产分娩问题很大,就像一种长期疾病,阻碍了她们从事经济活动和照顾孩子的能力。在孕产妇豁免政策背景下,剖宫产分娩限制了妇女为自己和新生儿获得进一步健康保险的能力,使长期获得医疗保健变得不确定。研究结果还表明,剖宫产的长期影响可能超出母婴的身体健康,还包括其他社会文化和背景方面的挑战。
因此,剖宫产使妇女处于多方面的脆弱境地。这凸显了发展中国家制定适合具体情况的孕产妇保健计划的必要性。