Atherley Anique, Taylor Charles
Faculty of Medical Sciences, the University of the West Indies, Cave Hill, Barbados.
Clin Teach. 2017 Aug;14(4):242-246. doi: 10.1111/tct.12538. Epub 2016 Jun 16.
When students transition into new clerkships, it can be useful to provide them with information to assist them in their adjustment to the new social environment. Handbooks could support students by providing information, particularly during clerkship orientation. The authors explored aspects of existing handbooks that students found useful, and sought additional desirable content.
During seven semi-structured focus group discussions, 48 final-year medical students discussed their perceptions of six handbooks at the end of their training. Focus group discussions continued until data saturation. Transcripts were thematically analysed.
Students appreciated handbooks that were concise, and valued reviewing handbooks with faculty members who could highlight important content. Most students valued and desired content related to assessment, and specifically used handbooks when preparing for examinations. Most students appreciated handbooks that provided study guidance such as a syllabus. Students also appreciated logistical aspects such as a timetable and information on clerkship cultural norms. Students disliked handbooks with vague descriptions of faculty member expectations and students' roles.
Students liked, disliked and desired many aspects of clerkship handbooks. The findings of our study could be used when designing handbooks to enhance their perceived value to students. Further research is needed on the impact of handbooks on learning and increasing students' engagement with handbook content. There are many aspects of handbook content and delivery that could be used to improve students' perceptions regarding handbooks. Handbooks could support students by providing information.
当学生过渡到新的临床实习时,为他们提供信息以帮助他们适应新的社会环境可能会很有用。手册可以通过提供信息来支持学生,特别是在临床实习迎新期间。作者探讨了学生认为有用的现有手册的各个方面,并寻求其他理想的内容。
在七次半结构化焦点小组讨论中,48名医学专业最后一年的学生在培训结束时讨论了他们对六本手册的看法。焦点小组讨论持续进行,直到数据饱和。对访谈记录进行了主题分析。
学生们欣赏简洁的手册,并重视与能够突出重要内容的教员一起复习手册。大多数学生重视并希望获得与评估相关的内容,特别是在准备考试时使用手册。大多数学生欣赏提供学习指导(如教学大纲)的手册。学生们也欣赏后勤方面的内容,如时间表和临床实习文化规范信息。学生们不喜欢对手教员期望和学生角色描述模糊的手册。
学生们对临床实习手册的许多方面有喜欢、不喜欢和期望。我们的研究结果可用于设计手册时,以提高学生对其的感知价值。需要进一步研究手册对学习的影响以及增加学生对手册内容的参与度。手册内容和交付的许多方面可用于改善学生对手册的看法。手册可以通过提供信息来支持学生。