Zaballa I, Eidemüller M
Institute of Radiation Protection, Helmholtz Zentrum München, 85764, Neuherberg, Germany.
Radiat Environ Biophys. 2016 Aug;55(3):299-315. doi: 10.1007/s00411-016-0659-0. Epub 2016 Jun 22.
Lung cancer mortality after radon exposure in the Wismut cohort was analyzed using the two-stage clonal expansion (TSCE) model. A total of 2996 lung cancer deaths among the 58,695 male workers were observed during the follow-up period between 1946 and 2003. Adjustment to silica exposure was performed to find a more accurate estimation of the risk of radon exposure. An additional analysis with the descriptive excess relative risk (ERR) model was carried out for comparison. The TSCE model that best describes the data is nonlinear in the clonal expansion with radon exposure and has a saturation level at an exposure rate of [Formula: see text]. The excess relative risk decreases with age and shows an inverse exposure rate effect. In comparison with the ERR model, the TSCE model predicts a considerably larger risk for low exposures rates below [Formula: see text]. Comparison to other mechanistic studies of lung cancer after exposure to alpha particles using the TSCE model reveals an extraordinary consistency in the main features of the exposure response, given the diversity in the characteristics of the cohorts and the exposure across different studies. This suggests that a nonlinear response mechanism in the clonal expansion, with some level of saturation at large exposure rates, may be playing a crucial role in the development of lung cancer after alpha particle irradiation.
利用两阶段克隆扩增(TSCE)模型分析了维姆施图特队列中氡暴露后的肺癌死亡率。在1946年至2003年的随访期间,在58695名男性工人中总共观察到2996例肺癌死亡病例。对二氧化硅暴露进行了调整,以更准确地估计氡暴露风险。还进行了描述性超额相对风险(ERR)模型的额外分析以作比较。最能描述数据的TSCE模型在克隆扩增与氡暴露方面是非线性的,并且在暴露率为[公式:见正文]时具有饱和水平。超额相对风险随年龄降低,并呈现出暴露率反比效应。与ERR模型相比,TSCE模型预测在低于[公式:见正文]的低暴露率下风险要大得多。使用TSCE模型与其他关于α粒子暴露后肺癌的机制研究进行比较发现,尽管不同研究中的队列特征和暴露情况存在差异,但暴露反应的主要特征却异常一致。这表明克隆扩增中的非线性反应机制,在高暴露率下有一定程度的饱和,可能在α粒子照射后肺癌的发生中起着关键作用。