Naoum Steven J, Lenard Andrea, Martin F Elizabeth, Ellakwa Ayman
Faculty of Dentistry, The University of Sydney, NSW, Australia; Westmead Centre for Oral Health, Westmead Hospital, Sydney, NSW 1245, Australia.
Int Sch Res Notices. 2015 Apr 2;2015:905019. doi: 10.1155/2015/905019. eCollection 2015.
Background. To assess the clinical efficacy of a dentifrice containing fluoride and functionalised tricalcium phosphate (fTCP) in reducing dentine sensitivity. Methods. A 10-week parallel blind randomised control trial was conducted. Subjects were assigned to one of four groups and instructed to brush twice daily: A: Colgate Cavity Protection (1000 ppmF-MFP); B: Sensodyne Total Care (1000 ppmF-NaF + 19300 ppmK(+)-KNO3); C: Clinpro Tooth Crème (950 ppmF-NaF + fTCP); and D: Clinpro Tooth Crème (brushing + additional topical application). Seventy-one patients were assessed at baseline, 6 weeks, and 10 weeks for cold, tactile, and hypertonic sensitivity using the NRS-11 pain rating scale. A combined modalities sensitivity score (CMS) was calculated. Results. At 6 weeks, patients reported the following reduction in CMS: A (20%); B (30%); C (42%); D (52%). At 10 weeks, patients reported the following reduction in CMS: A (18%), B (40%), C (24%), and D (54%). The only CMS comparisons to show a significant difference (P < 0.05) were between Groups A and D (6 and 10 weeks). Conclusions. Addition of fTCP to a dentifrice enhances the ability of dentifrice fluoride in reducing dentine sensitivity. Using Clinpro Tooth Crème twice daily for brushing can be as effective to reduce dentine sensitivity as twice daily brushing using Sensodyne Total Care. However, additional nightly topical application of fTCP, in addition to twice daily brushing, showed an enhanced reduction in dentine sensitivity.
背景。评估含氟和功能化磷酸三钙(fTCP)的牙膏在降低牙本质敏感方面的临床疗效。方法。进行了一项为期10周的平行双盲随机对照试验。受试者被分配到四组中的一组,并被指示每天刷牙两次:A组:高露洁防蛀牙膏(1000 ppm氟-单氟磷酸钠);B组:舒适达全效护理牙膏(1000 ppm氟-氟化钠+19300 ppm钾-硝酸钾);C组:Clinpro Tooth Crème牙膏(950 ppm氟-氟化钠+fTCP);D组:Clinpro Tooth Crème牙膏(刷牙+额外局部应用)。使用NRS-11疼痛评定量表在基线、6周和10周时对71名患者进行冷、触觉和高渗敏感性评估。计算综合模态敏感性评分(CMS)。结果。在6周时,患者报告的CMS降低情况如下:A组(20%);B组(30%);C组(42%);D组(52%)。在10周时,患者报告的CMS降低情况如下:A组(18%),B组(40%),C组(24%),D组(54%)。唯一显示出显著差异(P<0.05)的CMS比较是A组和D组之间(6周和10周)。结论。在牙膏中添加fTCP可增强牙膏中氟化物降低牙本质敏感的能力。每天使用两次Clinpro Tooth Crème牙膏刷牙在降低牙本质敏感方面与每天使用两次舒适达全效护理牙膏一样有效。然而除了每天刷牙两次外,每晚额外局部应用fTCP可增强降低牙本质敏感的效果。