Beckley Firle, Best Wendy, Beeke Suzanne
Division of Psychology and Language Sciences, University College London, London, UK.
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2017 Mar;52(2):197-213. doi: 10.1111/1460-6984.12265. Epub 2016 Jun 28.
Communication strategy training (CST) is a recognized part of UK speech and language therapists' (SLTs) role when working with a person with aphasia. Multiple CST interventions have been published but, to date, there are no published studies exploring clinical practice in this area.
To investigate UK SLTs' current CST practices.
METHODS & PROCEDURES: Thirty-seven UK SLTs completed an online questionnaire, eight of whom attended a follow-up focus group. A clinical consistency scale was applied to the questionnaire data and tasks that were most consistently used were explored in the focus group and analyzed using a primarily deductive thematic data analysis approach.
OUTCOMES & RESULTS: Three key CST findings arose: (1) the rarity with which SLTs focus equally and explicitly on both communication partners' strategies; (2) SLTs' differing understandings of CST terminologies and concepts and underuse of formal assessment; and (3) the absence of video feedback.
CONCLUSION & IMPLICATIONS: This study's survey findings suggest that conversation partners not only receive half the amount of CST given to people with aphasia but also play a more passive learning role when they are present. This is an interesting point to consider when the current evidence base contains stronger evidence for the effectiveness of conversation partner CST over other CST approaches, it being described as an effective method that may be maintained over time.
沟通策略训练(CST)是英国言语和语言治疗师(SLT)在与失语症患者合作时所认可的工作内容的一部分。已有多篇关于多种CST干预措施的文献发表,但迄今为止,尚无关于该领域临床实践的研究发表。
调查英国言语和语言治疗师目前的CST实践情况。
37名英国言语和语言治疗师完成了一份在线问卷,其中8人参加了后续的焦点小组。将临床一致性量表应用于问卷数据,并在焦点小组中探讨了最常使用的任务,并采用主要是演绎性的主题数据分析方法进行分析。
出现了CST的三个关键发现:(1)言语和语言治疗师很少平等且明确地关注沟通双方的策略;(2)言语和语言治疗师对CST术语和概念的理解不同,且较少使用正式评估;(3)缺乏视频反馈。
本研究的调查结果表明,对话伙伴不仅获得了给予失语症患者的CST量的一半,而且在参与时扮演着更被动的学习角色。当目前的证据基础包含更强的证据证明对话伙伴CST比其他CST方法更有效,且被描述为一种可以长期维持的有效方法时,这是一个值得考虑的有趣问题。