de Oliveira César Osório, Carvalho Luciane Bc, Carlos Karla, Conti Cristiane, de Oliveira Marcio M, Prado Lucila Bf, Prado Gilmar F
Department of Neurology, Escola Paulista de Medicina, Universidade Federal de São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2016 Jun 29;2016(6):CD006941. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD006941.pub2.
Restless legs syndrome (RLS) is a distressing and common neurological disorder that may have a huge impact in the quality of life of those with frequent and intense symptoms. Patients complain of unpleasant sensations in the legs, at or before bedtime, and feel an urge to move the legs, which improves with movement, such as walking. Symptoms start with the patient at rest (e.g. sitting or lying down), and follow a circadian pattern, increasing during the evening or at night. Many pharmacological intervention are available for RLS, including drugs used to treat Parkinson's disease (L-Dopa and dopaminergic agonists), epilepsy (anticonvulsants), anxiety (benzodiazepines), and pain (opioids). Dopaminergic drugs are those most frequently used for treatment of RLS, but some patients do not respond effectively and require other medication. Opioids, a class of medications used to treat severe pain, seem to be effective in treating RLS symptoms, and are recommended for patients with severe symptoms, because RLS and pain appear to share the same mechanism in the central nervous system. All available drugs are associated to some degree with side effects, which can impede treatment. Opioids are associated with adverse events such as constipation, tolerance, and dependence. This justifies the conduct of a systematic review to ascertain whether opioids are safe and effective for treatment of RLS.
To asses the effects of opioids compared to placebo treatment for restless legs syndrome in adults.
We searched the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled trials, CENTRAL 2016, issue 4 and MEDLINE, EMBASE, and LILACS up to April 2016, using a search strategy adapted by Cochraneto identify randomised clinical trials. We checked the references of each study and established personal communication with other authors to identify any additional studies. We considered publications in all languages.
Randomised controlled clinical trials of opioid treatment in adults with idiopathic RLS.
Two review authors independently screened articles, independently extracted data into a standard form, and assessed for risk of bias. If necessary, they discussed discrepancies with a third researcher to resolve any doubts.
We included one randomised clinical trial (N = 304 randomised; 204 completed; 276 analysed) that evaluated opioids (prolonged release oxycodone/naloxone) versus placebo. After 12 weeks, RSL symptoms had improved more in the drug group than in the placebo group (using the IRLSSS: MD -7.0; 95% CI -9.69 to -4.31 and the CGI: MD -1.11; 95% CI -1.49 to -0.73). More patients in the drug group than in the placebo group were drug responders (using the IRLSSS: RR 1.82; 95% CI 1.37 to 2.42 and the CGI: RR1.92; 95% ICI 1.49 to 2.48). The proportion of remitters was greater in the drug group than in the placebo group (using the IRLSSS: RR 2.14; 95% CI 1.45 to 3.16). Quality of life scores also improved more in the drug group than in the placebo group (MD -0.73; 95% CI -1.1 to -0.36). Quality of sleep was improved more in the drug group measured by sleep adequacy (MD -0.74; 95% CI -1.15 to -0.33), and sleep quantity (MD 0.89; 95% CI 0.52 to 1.26).There was no difference between groups for daytime somnolence, trouble staying awake during the day, or naps during the day. More adverse events were reported in the drug group (RR 1.22; 95% CI 1.07 to 1.39). The major adverse events were gastrointestinal problems, fatigue, and headache.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: Opioids seem to be effective for treating RLS symptoms, but there are no definitive data regarding the important problem of safety. This conclusion is based on only one study with a high dropout rate (moderate quality evidence).
不宁腿综合征(RLS)是一种令人痛苦且常见的神经系统疾病,对于那些症状频繁且严重的患者,其生活质量可能会受到巨大影响。患者会在临睡前或睡前抱怨腿部出现不适感觉,并感到有移动腿部的冲动,而这种冲动通过诸如行走等活动会得到缓解。症状在患者休息时(如坐着或躺下)开始出现,并呈现昼夜节律模式,在傍晚或夜间会加重。有许多药物可用于治疗RLS,包括用于治疗帕金森病的药物(左旋多巴和多巴胺能激动剂)、癫痫(抗惊厥药)、焦虑症(苯二氮䓬类药物)以及疼痛(阿片类药物)。多巴胺能药物是治疗RLS最常用的药物,但一些患者对此反应不佳,需要使用其他药物。阿片类药物是一类用于治疗严重疼痛的药物,似乎对治疗RLS症状有效,并且推荐给症状严重的患者,因为RLS和疼痛在中枢神经系统中似乎具有相同的机制。所有可用药物在某种程度上都与副作用相关,这可能会妨碍治疗。阿片类药物与诸如便秘、耐受性和依赖性等不良事件相关。这证明了进行系统评价以确定阿片类药物治疗RLS是否安全有效的合理性。
评估与安慰剂治疗相比,阿片类药物对成人不宁腿综合征的疗效。
我们检索了Cochrane对照试验中央注册库(CENTRAL 2016年第4期)以及截至2016年4月的MEDLINE、EMBASE和LILACS,使用Cochrane改编的检索策略来识别随机临床试验。我们检查了每项研究的参考文献,并与其他作者建立个人联系以识别任何其他研究。我们考虑所有语言的出版物。
关于阿片类药物治疗成人特发性RLS的随机对照临床试验。
两位综述作者独立筛选文章,独立将数据提取到标准表格中,并评估偏倚风险。如有必要,他们会与第三位研究人员讨论差异以解决任何疑问。
我们纳入了一项随机临床试验(N = 304例随机分组;204例完成;276例分析),该试验评估了阿片类药物(缓释羟考酮/纳洛酮)与安慰剂的对比。12周后,药物组的RLS症状改善程度超过安慰剂组(使用国际不宁腿综合征评分量表(IRLSSS):MD -7.0;95% CI -9.69至-4.31,以及临床总体印象量表(CGI):MD -1.11;95% CI -1.49至-0.73)。药物组中药物反应者的比例高于安慰剂组(使用IRLSSS:RR 1.82;95% CI 1.37至2.42,以及CGI:RR1.92;95% CI 1.49至2.48)。缓解者的比例在药物组中高于安慰剂组(使用IRLSSS:RR 2.14;95% CI 1.45至3.16)。药物组的生活质量评分改善程度也高于安慰剂组(MD -0.73;95% CI -1.1至-0.36)。通过睡眠充足度(MD -0.74;95% CI -1.15至-0.33)和睡眠量(MD 0.89;95% CI 从0.52至1.26)衡量,药物组的睡眠质量改善程度更高。两组在白天嗜睡、白天难以保持清醒或白天小睡方面没有差异。药物组报告的不良事件更多(RR 1.22;95% CI从1.07至1.39)。主要不良事件是胃肠道问题、疲劳和头痛。
阿片类药物似乎对治疗RLS症状有效,但关于安全性这一重要问题尚无确切数据。这一结论仅基于一项脱落率较高的研究(中等质量证据)。