Coutinho Franzina, Bosisio Marie-Elaine, Brown Emma, Rishikof Stephanie, Skaf Elise, Zhang Xiaoting, Perlman Cynthia, Kelly Shannon, Freedin Erin, Dahan-Oliel Noemi
a School of Physical and Occupational Therapy, Faculty of Medicine, McGill University , Montreal , Quebec , Canada.
b Centre de Réadaptation MAB-Mackay , Occupational Therapy, Montreal , Quebec , Canada.
Disabil Rehabil Assist Technol. 2017 May;12(4):402-410. doi: 10.1080/17483107.2016.1185648. Epub 2016 Jul 4.
The aim of this randomized controlled trial was to assess the effectiveness of interventions using iPad applications compared to traditional occupational therapy on visual-motor integration (VMI) in school-aged children with poor VMI skills.
Twenty children aged 4y0m to 7y11m with poor VMI skills were randomly assigned to the experimental group (interventions using iPad apps targeting VMI skills) or control group (traditional occupational therapy intervention sessions targeting VMI skills). The intervention phase consisted of two 40-min sessions per week, over a period of 10 weeks. Participants were required to attend a minimum of 8 and a maximum of 12 sessions. The subjects were tested using the Beery-VMI and the visual-motor subscale of the M-FUN, at baseline and follow-up.
Results from a 2-way mixed design ANOVA yielded significant results for the main effect of time for the M-FUN total raw score, as well as in the subscales Amazing Mazes, Hidden Forks, Go Fishing and VM Behavior. However, gains did not differ between intervention types over time. No significant results were found for the Beery-VMI.
This study supports the need for further research into the use of iPads for the development of VMI skills in the pediatric population. Implications for Rehabilitation This is the first study to look at the use of iPads with school-aged children with poor visual-motor skills. There is limited literature related to the use of iPads in pediatric occupational therapy, while they are increasingly being used in practice. When compared to the traditional occupational therapy interventions, participants in the iPad intervention appeared to be more interested, engaged and motivated to participate in the therapy sessions. Using iPad apps as an adjunct to therapy in intervention could be effective in improving VMI skills over time.
本随机对照试验的目的是评估与传统职业治疗相比,使用iPad应用程序干预对视觉运动整合(VMI)技能较差的学龄儿童VMI的有效性。
20名年龄在4岁0个月至7岁11个月、VMI技能较差的儿童被随机分配到实验组(使用针对VMI技能的iPad应用程序进行干预)或对照组(针对VMI技能的传统职业治疗干预课程)。干预阶段包括每周两次40分钟的课程,为期10周。参与者需要至少参加8次,最多参加12次课程。在基线和随访时,使用贝利VMI测试和M-FUN视觉运动分量表对受试者进行测试。
双向混合设计方差分析的结果显示,M-FUN总分的时间主效应以及“神奇迷宫”“隐藏叉点”“钓鱼”和“VM行为”分量表均有显著结果。然而,随着时间的推移,不同干预类型之间的增益没有差异。贝利VMI测试未发现显著结果。
本研究支持有必要进一步研究在儿科人群中使用iPad来发展VMI技能。康复意义这是第一项研究在视觉运动技能较差的学龄儿童中使用iPad的研究。虽然iPad在儿科职业治疗中的应用越来越广泛,但相关文献有限。与传统职业治疗干预相比,iPad干预组的参与者似乎对治疗课程更感兴趣、更投入且更有积极性。随着时间的推移,将iPad应用程序作为治疗辅助手段可能有效地提高VMI技能。