Everson Jordan, Adler-Milstein Julia
Jordan Everson (
Julia Adler-Milstein is an assistant professor in the School of Information, University of Michigan, with a joint appointment in the Department of Health Management and Policy, School of Public Health.
Health Aff (Millwood). 2016 Jul 1;35(7):1286-93. doi: 10.1377/hlthaff.2015.1215.
Health information exchange (HIE) is intended to enable better, more efficient health care by electronically transferring patient data across provider organizations. Many policy makers, including members of Congress, are concerned that some electronic health record (EHR) vendors may be impeding this effort by making cross-vendor HIE difficult. We used national data to assess how market dominance by EHR vendors was related to hospitals' engagement in HIE in 2012 and 2013. Across all levels of vendor market dominance, hospitals using EHR systems supplied by the dominant vendor engaged in an average of 45 percent more HIE activities than hospitals not using the dominant vendor. However, when the dominant vendor controlled a small proportion-20 percent-of the market, hospitals using the dominant vendor engaged in 59 percent more HIE activities than hospitals using a different vendor. Conversely, when the dominant vendor controlled 80 percent of the market, hospitals using that vendor engaged in only 25 percent more HIE activities than hospitals using a different vendor. In markets with low vendor dominance, hospitals may engage in less HIE with hospitals using other vendors' systems, compared to markets with high vendor dominance, because of high costs and competitive barriers. Policies designed to promote cross-vendor HIE may need to take local market competition into account.
健康信息交换(HIE)旨在通过跨医疗机构电子传输患者数据,实现更好、更高效的医疗保健。包括国会议员在内的许多政策制定者担心,一些电子健康记录(EHR)供应商可能会通过制造跨供应商的健康信息交换困难来阻碍这项工作。我们利用全国数据评估了2012年和2013年电子健康记录供应商的市场主导地位与医院参与健康信息交换之间的关系。在供应商市场主导地位的所有层面上,使用主导供应商提供的电子健康记录系统的医院,其参与健康信息交换活动的平均数量比未使用主导供应商系统的医院多45%。然而,当主导供应商控制的市场份额较小时(20%),使用主导供应商系统的医院参与健康信息交换活动的数量比使用其他供应商系统的医院多59%。相反,当主导供应商控制80%的市场时,使用该供应商系统的医院参与健康信息交换活动的数量仅比使用其他供应商系统的医院多25%在供应商主导地位较低的市场中,与供应商主导地位较高的市场相比,医院与使用其他供应商系统的医院之间的健康信息交换可能较少,原因是成本高昂和存在竞争障碍。旨在促进跨供应商健康信息交换的政策可能需要考虑当地市场竞争情况。