Copeman R C, Swannell R J, Pincus D F, Woodhead K A
Department of Social and Preventive Medicine, University of Queensland Medical School, Herston.
Med J Aust. 1989 Jul 17;151(2):83-7. doi: 10.5694/j.1326-5377.1989.tb101167.x.
General practitioners have been encouraged to be more active in helping their patients to stop smoking. A number of research studies overseas and in Australia has reported that they can be effective in this form of health promotion. The "Smokescreen" programme is an intensive, structured antismoking intervention that was developed for use by general practitioners in Australia. To monitor the effect of this programme, general practitioners who had attended workshops on the use of the programme were contacted 12 months later to find out what use they had made of the programme, and how effective it had been. Only 18 of the 38 doctors who initially agreed to cooperate in the study had recruited smokers to the programme and had kept records of their progress. These 18 doctors had recruited 121 smokers in the 12-month period: only 7% (approximately) of all their patients who smoked. Of these, 29 (24%) patients reported that they had stopped smoking. Reasons that were given by doctors for their inability to use the programme as fully as they had hoped included the difficulty in recruiting smokers, a lack of time, and a low rate of return by the patients for follow-up visits. These results suggest that while general practitioners should be encouraged to give brief antismoking advice, general practice may not be a suitable location for more-intensive antismoking programmes. Limited health-promotional funds may be deployed better in general community awareness and mass-media programmes.
全科医生一直被鼓励在帮助患者戒烟方面更加积极主动。海外及澳大利亚的一些研究报告称,他们在这种形式的健康促进中可以发挥作用。“烟幕”计划是一项针对澳大利亚全科医生开发的密集型、结构化的戒烟干预措施。为了监测该计划的效果,在参加了关于该计划使用的研讨会12个月后,联系了这些全科医生,了解他们对该计划的使用情况以及效果如何。最初同意参与该研究的38名医生中,只有18名医生招募了吸烟者参加该计划,并记录了他们的进展情况。在这12个月期间,这18名医生共招募了121名吸烟者,约占他们所有吸烟患者的7%。其中,29名(24%)患者报告称他们已经戒烟。医生们给出的未能充分使用该计划的原因包括招募吸烟者困难、时间不足以及患者随访回访率低。这些结果表明,虽然应该鼓励全科医生提供简短的戒烟建议,但全科医疗可能不是开展更密集戒烟计划的合适场所。有限的健康促进资金或许可以更好地用于提高社区总体认识和大众媒体计划。