Richmond R, Webster I
Int J Epidemiol. 1985 Sep;14(3):396-401. doi: 10.1093/ije/14.3.396.
A study was made of a smoking cessation programme in a four-man general practice to determine the efficacy of general practitioner counselling and follow-up. In the treatment group 33% of patients became abstainers at six months compared with 3% in the control group. Self-reports of smoking status were verified by blood tests. Patients were more successful if they attended the first three visits compared with those who did not fully attend (48%: 6%). Continuing smokers had significantly higher blood concentrations of cotinine, thiocyanate and carboxyhaemoglobin per cigarette smoked at six months than at entry, despite a 30% decrease in stated cigarette consumption. This suggests that when smokers reduce the number of cigarettes smoked they compensate by increased inhalation. If general practitioners in Australia widely used the intervention programme with similar success this could have a major impact on the smoking habits of the three million smokers in Australia between 16 and 65 years of age. The total cost of the visits is a fraction of the medical treatment for a cigarette-related disease.
在一个四人全科诊所开展了一项戒烟项目研究,以确定全科医生咨询和随访的效果。治疗组中33%的患者在六个月时戒烟,而对照组为3%。吸烟状况的自我报告通过血液检测进行核实。与未全程就诊的患者相比,就诊前三次的患者戒烟成功率更高(48%:6%)。尽管报告的吸烟量减少了30%,但持续吸烟者在六个月时每吸一支烟的可替宁、硫氰酸盐和碳氧血红蛋白的血液浓度仍显著高于入组时。这表明,吸烟者减少吸烟数量时会通过增加吸入量来代偿。如果澳大利亚的全科医生广泛采用该干预项目并取得类似成效,这可能会对澳大利亚16至65岁的300万吸烟者的吸烟习惯产生重大影响。就诊的总成本只是与吸烟相关疾病医疗费用的一小部分。