Bärthel Gwennis A, Wessel Ineke, Huntjens Rafaële J C, Verwoerd Johan
a Clinical Psychology and Experimental Psychopathology , University of Groningen , Groningen , The Netherlands.
Memory. 2017 May;25(5):636-646. doi: 10.1080/09658211.2016.1208248. Epub 2016 Jul 12.
Research on collaborative remembering suggests that collaboration hampers group memory (i.e., collaborative inhibition), yet enhances later individual memory. Studies examining collaborative effects on memory for emotional stimuli are scarce, especially concerning later individual memory. In the present study, female undergraduates watched an emotional movie and recalled it either collaboratively (n = 60) or individually (n = 60), followed by an individual free recall test and a recognition test. We replicated the standard collaborative inhibition effect. Further, in line with the literature, the collaborative condition displayed better post-collaborative individual memory. More importantly, in post-collaborative free recall, the centrality of the information to the movie plot did not play an important role. Recognition rendered slightly different results. Although collaboration rendered more correct recognition for more central details, it did not enhance recognition of background details. Secondly, the collaborative and individual conditions did not differ with respect to overlap of unique correct items in free recall. Yet, during recognition former collaborators more unanimously endorsed correct answers, as well as errors. Finally, extraversion, neuroticism, social anxiety, and depressive symptoms did not moderate the influence of collaboration on memory. Implications for the fields of forensic and clinical psychology are discussed.
关于协同记忆的研究表明,合作会妨碍群体记忆(即协同抑制),但会增强之后的个体记忆。考察合作对情绪刺激记忆影响的研究很少,尤其是关于之后的个体记忆。在本研究中,女大学生观看一部情感电影,然后分别以合作方式(n = 60)或单独方式(n = 60)进行回忆,随后进行个体自由回忆测试和识别测试。我们重现了标准的协同抑制效应。此外,与文献一致,合作条件下表现出更好的合作后个体记忆。更重要的是,在合作后的自由回忆中,信息对电影情节的核心程度并未起到重要作用。识别测试得出了略有不同的结果。虽然合作对更核心细节的识别更正确,但并未增强对背景细节的识别。其次,在自由回忆中,合作组和单独组在独特正确项目的重叠方面没有差异。然而,在识别测试中,前合作者对正确答案以及错误答案的认可更为一致。最后,外向性、神经质、社交焦虑和抑郁症状并未调节合作对记忆的影响。本文还讨论了该研究对法医和临床心理学领域的启示。