Campbell S, Watkins G, Kreis D
Department of Surgery, University of South Florida, Tampa.
Am Surg. 1989 Jul;55(7):478-80.
Organized paramedic care was established in 1974 in Hillsborough County, Florida, with subsequent development of a hospital self-designation system for trauma in 1980. To evaluate the level of trauma care in the county, a review of trauma deaths in 1984 was performed. A total of 452 trauma deaths was identified. Of these, 191 deaths occurred at the scene. The remaining 261 patients were transported to one of six hospitals within the county. One hundred ninety-nine subsequent deaths were attributed to central nervous system (CNS) injury, while 62 deaths were secondary to non-CNS injuries. By the method of group review, 14 (22.6%) preventable non-CNS trauma deaths were identified. Six women died and eight men died; the mean age of the deceased was 44. Ten deaths (71.4%) were secondary to blunt trauma. Mean ISS score was 21.1. Eleven deaths (79%) were due to delay to the OR, 2 deaths (14%) were due to inadequate resuscitation, and 1 death (7%) was due to lack of surgical intervention. This study demonstrates that a self-designation system without regulatory control results in a high percentage of preventable trauma deaths. We conclude that established trauma systems are needed in all areas, including those that have had organized prehospital and hospital levels of care.
1974年,有组织的护理急救服务在佛罗里达州希尔斯伯勒县建立,随后在1980年发展出一种医院自行指定的创伤治疗体系。为评估该县的创伤治疗水平,对1984年的创伤死亡病例进行了回顾。共确定了452例创伤死亡病例。其中,191例死于现场。其余261名患者被送往该县的六家医院之一。随后有199例死亡归因于中枢神经系统(CNS)损伤,62例死亡继发于非CNS损伤。通过小组审查的方法,确定了14例(22.6%)可预防的非CNS创伤死亡病例。6名女性死亡,8名男性死亡;死者的平均年龄为44岁。10例死亡(71.4%)继发于钝器伤。平均损伤严重度评分(ISS)为21.1。11例死亡(79%)是由于延迟手术,2例死亡(14%)是由于复苏不足,1例死亡(7%)是由于缺乏手术干预。本研究表明,缺乏监管控制的自行指定体系会导致很高比例的可预防创伤死亡。我们得出结论,所有地区都需要建立创伤治疗体系,包括那些已经具备有组织的院前和医院护理水平的地区。