McCabe Jennifer D, Olsen Brian J, Hiebeler David
Department of Forestry and Wildlife Ecology, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, Wisconsin, 53706.
School of Biology & Ecology, Climate Change Institute, University of Maine, Orono, Maine, 04469.
Evolution. 2016 Sep;70(9):2145-54. doi: 10.1111/evo.13007. Epub 2016 Aug 30.
Suture zones are areas where range contact zones and hybrid zones of multiple taxa are clustered. Migratory divides, contact zones between divergent populations that breed adjacent to one another but use different migratory routes, are a particular case of suture zones. Although multiple hypotheses for both the formation and maintenance of migratory divides have been suggested, quantitative tests are scarce. Here, we tested whether a novel factor, prevailing winds, was sufficient to explain both the evolution and maintenance of the Cordilleran migratory divide using individual-based models. Empirical observations of eastern birds suggest a circuitous migratory route across Canada before heading south. Western breeders, however, travel south along the Pacific coast to their wintering grounds. We modeled the effect of wind on bird migratory flights by allowing them to float at elevation using spatially explicit modeled wind data. Modeled eastern birds had easterly mean trajectories, whereas western breeders showed significantly more southern trajectories. We also determined that a mean airspeed of 18.5 m s(-1) would be necessary to eliminate this difference in trajectory, a speed that is achieved by waterfowl and shorebirds, but is faster than songbird flight speeds. These results lend support for the potential importance of wind in shaping the phylogeographic history of North American songbirds.
缝合带是多个分类单元的分布范围接触带和杂交带聚集的区域。迁徙分界线是相邻繁殖但使用不同迁徙路线的不同种群之间的接触带,是缝合带的一种特殊情况。尽管已经提出了多种关于迁徙分界线形成和维持的假说,但定量测试却很少。在这里,我们使用基于个体的模型测试了一个新的因素——盛行风,是否足以解释科迪勒拉迁徙分界线的演化和维持。对东部鸟类的实证观察表明,它们在向南迁徙之前会沿着一条迂回的路线穿越加拿大。然而,西部繁殖鸟类则沿着太平洋海岸向南前往它们的越冬地。我们通过使用空间明确的模拟风数据让鸟类在高空漂浮,来模拟风对鸟类迁徙飞行的影响。模拟的东部鸟类平均轨迹为东风向,而西部繁殖鸟类的轨迹则明显更偏南。我们还确定,平均空速达到18.5米/秒才能消除轨迹上的这种差异,这个速度水禽和滨鸟能够达到,但比鸣禽的飞行速度要快。这些结果支持了风在塑造北美鸣禽系统发育历史方面可能具有重要作用的观点。