Radetić Luka, Vujević Dinko, Premur Vitomir, Melnjak Ivana, Anić Vučinić Aleksandra
University of Zagreb, Faculty of Geotechnical Engineering, Department of Environmental Engineering, HR-42000 Varaždin, Croatia.
University of Zagreb, Faculty of Geotechnical Engineering, Department of Environmental Engineering, HR-42000 Varaždin, Croatia
Waste Manag Res. 2016 Oct;34(10):1047-1053. doi: 10.1177/0734242X16657609. Epub 2016 Jul 20.
The usage of old equipment (over 10-year-old diesel-fuelled waste collection vehicles, WCVs) for municipal solid waste (MSW) collection in Ludbreg for longer than a decade has had a negative environmental impact, which has been reduced by replacing an old diesel WCV with a new diesel WCV. This study aims to assess the share of air emissions of two old WCVs (FAP 1990 and MAN 2003) and one new (MAN 2015), expressed in CO emissions. In addition, these vehicles have been found easily to reach the limit of 100 dB, which can cause hearing damage in their surroundings. Furthermore, their average fuel consumption is more than 80 l per 100 km, which makes them ineffective in terms of fuel consumption. Generally, higher fuel consumption results in more emissions and for a more eco-friendly operation, the MAN 2003 from Ludbreg WCV fleet should be technically amended and adjusted, and the FAP 1990 should be retired. Although the MAN 2015 is diesel fuelled, the best solution for replacement, according to Maimoun et al. (Waste Management 33: 1079-1089, 2016), would be the use of hydraulic-hybrid vehicles, which provide the best environmental benefits over other alternatives. According to Maimoun et al., hybrid is better environmentally, diesel is the best environmental-economical option and landfill gas-sourced natural gas is the best alternative when accessible because it significantly (up to 80%) reduces emissions of hazardous gases as well as noise levels (50-98%).
在卢德布雷格,使用超过10年的旧设备(以柴油为燃料的垃圾收集车,WCV)收集城市固体废物(MSW)长达十多年,已对环境产生负面影响,而用一辆新的柴油WCV替换旧的柴油WCV后,这种影响有所减轻。本研究旨在评估两辆旧WCV(FAP 1990和MAN 2003)和一辆新WCV(MAN 2015)的空气排放份额,以一氧化碳排放量表示。此外,已发现这些车辆很容易达到100分贝的限值,这可能会对其周围环境造成听力损害。此外,它们的平均油耗超过每100公里80升,这使得它们在油耗方面效率低下。一般来说,更高的油耗会导致更多的排放,为了实现更环保的运营,卢德布雷格WCV车队的MAN 2003应进行技术改造和调整,FAP 1990应淘汰。尽管MAN 2015是以柴油为燃料的,但根据迈蒙等人(《废物管理》33:1079 - 1089,2016)的说法,最佳的替代方案是使用液压混合动力车辆,与其他替代方案相比,它能带来最佳的环境效益。根据迈蒙等人的说法,混合动力在环境方面更好,柴油是最佳的环境经济选择,而当可获取时,垃圾填埋气来源的天然气是最佳替代方案,因为它能显著(高达80%)减少有害气体排放以及噪音水平(50 - 98%)。