Ocampo Denise, Booth Mark
Department of Anthropology, Durham University, Stockton Rd, Durham, UK.
School of Medicine, Pharmacy and Health, Durham University, University Boulevard, Thornaby, UK.
Malar J. 2016 Jul 22;15(1):383. doi: 10.1186/s12936-016-1446-8.
Current interventions against malaria have significantly reduced the number of people infected and the number of deaths. Concerns about emerging resistance of both mosquitoes and parasites to intervention have been raised, and questions remain about how best to generate wider knowledge of the underlying evolutionary processes. The pedagogical and research principles of evolutionary medicine may provide an answer to this problem.
Eight programme managers and five academic researchers were interviewed by telephone or videoconference to elicit their first-hand views and experiences of malaria control given that evolution is a constant threat to sustainable control. Interviewees were asked about their views on the relationship between practit groups and academics and for their thoughts on whether or not evolutionary medicine may provide a solution to reported tensions.
There was broad agreement that evolution of both parasites and vectors presents an obstacle to sustainable control. It was also widely agreed that through more efficient monitoring, evolution could be widely monitored. Interviewees also expressed the view that even well planned interventions may fail if the evolutionary biology of the disease is not considered, potentially making current tools redundant.
This scoping study suggests that it is important to make research, including evolutionary principles, available and easily applicable for programme managers and key decision-makers, including donors and politicians. The main conclusion is that sharing knowledge through the educational and research processes embedded within evolutionary medicine has potential to relieve tensions and facilitate sustainable control of malaria and other parasitic infections.
当前的疟疾防治措施已显著减少了感染人数和死亡人数。人们对蚊子和寄生虫对防治措施产生新耐药性的担忧不断增加,对于如何更好地让人们更广泛地了解潜在进化过程的问题依然存在。进化医学的教学和研究原则或许能为这个问题提供答案。
通过电话或视频会议采访了8名项目管理人员和5名学术研究人员,以获取他们在进化对可持续防治构成持续威胁的情况下,对疟疾控制的第一手观点和经验。受访者被问及他们对实践群体与学者之间关系的看法,以及他们对进化医学是否可能为所报告的紧张关系提供解决方案的想法。
大家普遍认为寄生虫和病媒的进化是可持续防治的障碍。还普遍认为,通过更有效的监测,可以广泛监测进化情况。受访者还表示,如果不考虑疾病的进化生物学,即使精心规划的干预措施也可能失败,这可能会使现有工具变得无用。
这项范围界定研究表明,让包括进化原理在内的研究成果可供项目管理人员以及包括捐助者和政治家在内的关键决策者获取并易于应用非常重要。主要结论是,通过进化医学所包含的教育和研究过程分享知识,有可能缓解紧张关系,并促进疟疾和其他寄生虫感染的可持续防治。