Hayashi Takuji, Nozaki Daichi
Division of Physical and Health Education, Graduate School of Education, The University of TokyoTokyo, Japan; Japan Society for the Promotion of ScienceTokyo, Japan.
Division of Physical and Health Education, Graduate School of Education, The University of TokyoTokyo, Japan; Center for Barrier-Free Education, Graduate School of Education, The University of TokyoTokyo, Japan.
Front Integr Neurosci. 2016 Jul 14;10:25. doi: 10.3389/fnint.2016.00025. eCollection 2016.
When we learn a bimanual motor skill (e.g., rowing a boat), we often break it down into unimanual practices (e.g., a rowing drill with the left or right arm). Such unimanual practice is thought to be useful for learning bimanual motor skills efficiently because the learner can concentrate on learning to perform a simpler component. However, it is not so straightforward to assume that unimanual training (UT) improves bimanual performance. We have previously demonstrated that motor memories for reaching movements consist of three different parts: unimanual-specific, bimanual-specific, and overlapping parts. According to this scheme, UT appears to be less effective, as its training effect is only partially transferred to the same limb for bimanual movement. In the present study, counter-intuitively, we demonstrate that, even after the bimanual skill is almost fully learned by means of bimanual training (BT), additional UT could further improve bimanual skill. We hypothesized that this effect occurs because UT increases the memory content in the overlapping part, which might contribute to an increase in the memory for bimanual movement. To test this hypothesis, we examined whether the UT performed after sufficient BT could improve the bimanual performance. Participants practiced performing bimanual reaching movements (BM) in the presence of a novel force-field imposed only on their left arm. As an index for the motor performance, we used the error-clamp method (i.e., after-effect of the left arm) to evaluate the force output to compensate for the force-field during the reaching movement. After sufficient BT, the training effect reached a plateau. However, UT performed subsequently improved the bimanual performance significantly. In contrast, when the same amount of BT was continued, the bimanual performance remained unchanged, highlighting the beneficial effect of UT on bimanual performance. Considering memory structure, we also expected that BT could improve unimanual performance, which was confirmed by another experiment. These results provide a new interpretation of why UT was useful for improving a bimanual skill, and propose a practical strategy for enhancing performance by performing training in various contexts.
当我们学习一项双手运动技能(例如划船)时,我们常常会将其分解为单手练习(例如用左臂或右臂进行划船训练)。这种单手练习被认为有助于高效学习双手运动技能,因为学习者可以专注于学习执行一个更简单的组成部分。然而,认为单手训练(UT)能提高双手运动表现并非如此简单直接。我们之前已经证明,针对伸手动作的运动记忆由三个不同部分组成:特定于单手的部分、特定于双手的部分以及重叠部分。按照这个模式,UT似乎效果较差,因为其训练效果仅部分转移到用于双手运动的同一肢体上。在本研究中,与直觉相反,我们证明,即使在通过双手训练(BT)几乎完全学会双手技能之后,额外的UT仍可进一步提高双手技能。我们推测这种效果的出现是因为UT增加了重叠部分的记忆内容,这可能有助于增加对双手运动的记忆。为了验证这一推测,我们研究了在充分的BT之后进行的UT是否能改善双手运动表现。参与者在仅施加于其左臂的新型力场存在的情况下练习进行双手伸手动作(BM)。作为运动表现的指标,我们使用误差钳制方法(即左臂的后效应)来评估在伸手动作期间补偿力场的力输出。在充分的BT之后,训练效果达到了平稳状态。然而,随后进行的UT显著改善了双手运动表现。相比之下,当继续进行相同量的BT时,双手运动表现保持不变,突出了UT对双手运动表现的有益影响。考虑到记忆结构,我们还预期BT可以改善单手运动表现,这在另一个实验中得到了证实。这些结果为UT为何对提高双手技能有用提供了一种新的解释,并提出了一种通过在各种情境下进行训练来提高表现的实用策略。