Gero Daniel, Gié Olivier, Hübner Martin, Demartines Nicolas, Hahnloser Dieter
Department of Visceral Surgery, University Hospital CHUV, Rue du Bugnon 46, CH-1011, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Langenbecks Arch Surg. 2017 Feb;402(1):149-158. doi: 10.1007/s00423-016-1485-1. Epub 2016 Aug 3.
Postoperative ileus (POI) is a frequent complication after abdominal surgery; nonetheless, it remains poorly defined. Our aim was to achieve an international consensus among leading colorectal surgeons on definition, prevention, and treatment of POI.
Thirty-five experts from five continents participated in a three-round Delphi process. Round 1 contained open-ended questions on POI and postoperative nausea and vomiting (PONV). Round 2 included closed-ended questions. Round 3 measured agreement on a 5-point Likert scale. Consensus was defined when items were rated as agree or strongly agree by at least 70 % of the experts.
Experts reached following consensus: POI is a temporary inhibition (86 %) of gastrointestinal motility after surgical intervention due to non-mechanical causes (89 %) and prevents sufficient oral intake (96 %). Abdominal distension/tenderness are the most relevant clinical signs (71 %). Nasogastric tube placement is not mandatory (78 %) but can be removed without previous clamping (81 %)/gastrointestinal contrast study (100 %). Preventive measures are recommended to decrease the risk of POI (96 %): narcotic sparing analgesia (89 %) and fluid optimization (74 %). Treatment of POI should include stimulation of ambulation (96 %) and stop of opioids (74 %). Total parenteral nutrition is recommended from the 7th day without sufficient oral intake (81 %). There was no consensus on the ranking of POI's symptoms, on the imaging modality of choice for the diagnosis of POI, neither on the difference between POI and PONV.
This Delphi study achieved consensus on the definition, relevant clinical signs, prevention, treatment, and supportive care of POI. Areas of non-consensus were identified (necessity and modality of radiologic imaging to establish the diagnosis, difference between POI and PONV), giving opportunity for further research.
术后肠梗阻(POI)是腹部手术后常见的并发症;然而,其定义仍不明确。我们的目的是在结直肠外科领域的主要专家之间就POI的定义、预防和治疗达成国际共识。
来自五大洲的35位专家参与了三轮德尔菲法。第一轮包含关于POI和术后恶心呕吐(PONV)的开放式问题。第二轮包括封闭式问题。第三轮采用5级李克特量表衡量一致性。当至少70%的专家将项目评为同意或强烈同意时,即达成共识。
专家们达成了以下共识:POI是手术干预后由于非机械性原因导致的胃肠道动力暂时抑制(86%),并妨碍足够的经口摄入(96%)。腹胀/压痛是最相关的临床体征(71%)。鼻胃管置入并非必需(78%),但可在未预先夹闭(81%)/胃肠道造影检查(100%)的情况下拔除。建议采取预防措施以降低POI风险(96%):减少阿片类药物使用的镇痛(89%)和优化液体管理(74%)。POI的治疗应包括鼓励活动(96%)和停用阿片类药物(74%)。在经口摄入不足的情况下,建议从第7天开始给予全胃肠外营养(81%)。在POI症状的排序、POI诊断的首选影像学检查方式以及POI与PONV的区别方面未达成共识。
这项德尔菲研究在POI的定义、相关临床体征、预防、治疗和支持性护理方面达成了共识。确定了未达成共识的领域(用于确诊的放射学检查的必要性和方式、POI与PONV的区别),为进一步研究提供了机会。