Shi Yulu, Thrippleton Michael J, Makin Stephen D, Marshall Ian, Geerlings Mirjam I, de Craen Anton J M, van Buchem Mark A, Wardlaw Joanna M
Centre for Clinical Brain Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom Department of Neurology, Zhongnan Hospital, Wuhan University, Wuhan, China.
Centre for Clinical Brain Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
J Cereb Blood Flow Metab. 2016 Oct;36(10):1653-1667. doi: 10.1177/0271678X16662891. Epub 2016 Aug 5.
White matter hyperintensities are frequent on neuroimaging of older people and are a key feature of cerebral small vessel disease. They are commonly attributed to chronic hypoperfusion, although whether low cerebral blood flow is cause or effect is unclear. We systematically reviewed studies that assessed cerebral blood flow in small vessel disease patients, performed meta-analysis and sensitivity analysis of potential confounders. Thirty-eight studies (n = 4006) met the inclusion criteria, including four longitudinal and 34 cross-sectional studies. Most cerebral blood flow data were from grey matter. Twenty-four cross-sectional studies (n = 1161) were meta-analysed, showing that cerebral blood flow was lower in subjects with more white matter hyperintensity, globally and in most grey and white matter regions (e.g. mean global cerebral blood flow: standardised mean difference-0.71, 95% CI -1.12, -0.30). These cerebral blood flow differences were attenuated by excluding studies in dementia or that lacked age-matching. Four longitudinal studies (n = 1079) gave differing results, e.g., more baseline white matter hyperintensity predated falling cerebral blood flow (3.9 years, n = 575); cerebral blood flow was low in regions that developed white matter hyperintensity (1.5 years, n = 40). Cerebral blood flow is lower in subjects with more white matter hyperintensity cross-sectionally, but evidence for falling cerebral blood flow predating increasing white matter hyperintensity is conflicting. Future studies should be longitudinal, obtain more white matter data, use better age-correction and stratify by clinical diagnosis.
脑白质高信号在老年人的神经影像学检查中很常见,是脑小血管病的一个关键特征。它们通常归因于慢性灌注不足,尽管脑血流量降低是原因还是结果尚不清楚。我们系统地回顾了评估小血管病患者脑血流量的研究,并对潜在混杂因素进行了荟萃分析和敏感性分析。38项研究(n = 4006)符合纳入标准,包括4项纵向研究和34项横断面研究。大多数脑血流量数据来自灰质。对24项横断面研究(n = 1161)进行了荟萃分析,结果显示,在脑白质高信号较多的受试者中,整体以及大多数灰质和白质区域的脑血流量较低(例如,平均全脑血流量:标准化平均差-0.71,95%CI -1.12,-0.30)。通过排除痴呆研究或缺乏年龄匹配的研究,这些脑血流量差异有所减弱。4项纵向研究(n = 1079)给出了不同的结果,例如,更多的基线脑白质高信号先于脑血流量下降(3.9年,n = 575);在出现脑白质高信号的区域脑血流量较低(1.5年,n = 40)。横断面研究中,脑白质高信号较多的受试者脑血流量较低,但关于脑血流量下降先于脑白质高信号增加的证据存在矛盾。未来的研究应该是纵向的,获取更多的脑白质数据,使用更好的年龄校正方法,并按临床诊断进行分层。