Carr Gemma
Centre for Water Resource Systems Vienna University of Technology Vienna Austria.
WIREs Water. 2015 Jul-Aug;2(4):393-405. doi: 10.1002/wat2.1086. Epub 2015 Apr 17.
Participation of the public and stakeholders in river basin management is increasingly promoted because it is expected to improve resource management and enable participants to engage freely and equally in management (support democratic processes). Three overlapping and interacting mechanisms by which participation is expected to enhance river basin management are outlined: (1) providing space for deliberation and consensus building for better quality decisions, (2) mobilizing and developing human and social capital for better quality decisions and their implementation, and (3) raising the legitimacy of decisions to facilitate their implementation. There are several complexities associated with each of the mechanisms that add challenges to realizing the expectations of participation. They include the need to carefully manage consensus building and conflict to maximize the quality of the decision without jeopardizing the potential for implementation; being aware of and implementing strategies to manage asymmetrical power relationships between participants; ensuring that participants perceive benefits from participation that exceed costs; and defining criteria for a legitimate process, and a legitimate decision, that satisfy all participants. Strategies identified to address these challenges focus on managing the characteristics of the participation process. Ongoing evaluation during a participation program or project is essential to reflect and refine how participation is being done, to address the challenges and endeavor to achieve high-quality decisions that can be implemented efficiently. 2015, 2:393-405. doi: 10.1002/wat2.1086 For further resources related to this article, please visit the WIREs website.
公众和利益相关者参与流域管理正得到越来越多的推动,因为人们期望这能改善资源管理,并使参与者能够自由和平等地参与管理(支持民主进程)。本文概述了参与有望加强流域管理的三个相互重叠且相互作用的机制:(1)为审议和建立共识提供空间,以做出质量更高的决策;(2)调动和发展人力及社会资本,以做出质量更高的决策并加以实施;(3)提高决策的合法性,以促进其实施。每个机制都存在若干复杂情况,给实现参与的预期带来了挑战。这些复杂情况包括需要谨慎管理共识的建立和冲突,以在不危及实施可能性的前提下使决策质量最大化;意识到并实施管理参与者之间不对称权力关系的策略;确保参与者认为参与带来的好处超过成本;以及确定能让所有参与者都满意的合法程序和合法决策的标准。为应对这些挑战而确定的策略侧重于管理参与过程的特点。在参与计划或项目期间进行持续评估对于反思和完善参与方式、应对挑战以及努力做出能够有效实施的高质量决策至关重要。2015年,2:393 - 405。doi: 10.1002/wat2.1086 有关本文的更多资源,请访问WIREs网站。