Department of Neuroscience, Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU), Edvard Griegs Gate, Trondheim, NO-7491, Norway.
Division of Brain Sciences, Imperial College London, London, UK.
J Headache Pain. 2016 Dec;17(1):74. doi: 10.1186/s10194-016-0669-y. Epub 2016 Aug 25.
The Global Campaign against Headache has pioneered evaluation of the prevalence and impact of headache on the preceding day ("headache yesterday") as a new approach to the estimation of headache-attributed burden, avoiding recall error. We report its application in Karnataka State, southern India.
In a door-to-door survey, biologically unrelated adults (aged 18-65 years) were randomly sampled from urban and rural areas in and around Bengaluru and interviewed by trained researchers using a validated, structured questionnaire. Enquiry into headache applied ICHD-II diagnostic criteria and included questions about headache on the day preceding the interview (headache yesterday [HY]).
There were 2329 participants (participation proportion 92.6 %; males 1141 [49.0 %], females 1188 [51.0 %]; mean age 38.0 [±12.7] years; 1103 [47.4 %] from rural areas, 1226 [52.6 %] urban). HY was reported by 138 participants (males 33 [2.9 %], females 105 [8.8 %]): the 1-day prevalence of headache was 5.9 %. Mean duration of HY was 7.0 ± 8.5 h, so that 1.7 % of the population (5.9 % * 7.0/24), on average, had headache at any moment in time yesterday. Mean intensity on a scale of 1-3 was 2.0 [±0.8]. Lost productivity due to HY was reported by 83.3 % of participants with HY: 37.7 % able to do less than half of what they had planned and 13.0 % able to do nothing. Productivity loss at population level (being the productivity loss within the entire adult population, every single day, attributable to headache) was 3.0 %.
This method of enquiry, free from recall error, confirmed a very high level of headache-attributed burden in Karnataka: previous estimates based on 3-month recall may even have been too low. Until another study is done in the country, these are the best data for all India. They demonstrate need for action nationwide to mitigate this burden, and correct action will ultimately almost certainly be cost-saving.
全球头痛防治运动开创了评估前一天头痛的流行率和影响(“昨日头痛”)的先河,这是一种估计头痛负担的新方法,可避免回忆偏倚。我们报告了在印度南部卡纳塔克邦的应用情况。
在一项入户调查中,从班加罗尔及其周边城乡地区随机抽取生物上无关联的成年(18-65 岁)参与者,由经过培训的研究人员使用经过验证的结构化问卷进行访谈。询问头痛时采用 ICHD-II 诊断标准,并包括关于前一天头痛(昨日头痛[HY])的问题。
共有 2329 名参与者(参与率 92.6%;男性 1141 名[49.0%],女性 1188 名[51.0%];平均年龄 38.0[±12.7]岁;1103 名[47.4%]来自农村地区,1226 名[52.6%]来自城市)。138 名参与者报告了 HY(男性 33 名[2.9%],女性 105 名[8.8%]):1 天的头痛患病率为 5.9%。HY 的平均持续时间为 7.0[±8.5]小时,因此,平均而言,昨日任何时刻都有 1.7%的人口(5.9%*7.0/24)患有头痛。在 1-3 分的量表上,平均强度为 2.0[±0.8]。有 HY 的参与者中有 83.3%报告因 HY 而导致生产力下降:37.7%的人只能完成他们计划的一半以下,13.0%的人什么都做不了。HY 导致的人口级别的生产力损失(即整个成年人口中,由于头痛,每天损失的生产力)为 3.0%。
这种无回忆偏倚的询问方法证实了卡纳塔克邦头痛负担极高:以前基于 3 个月回顾的估计值甚至可能过低。在该国进行另一项研究之前,这些是全印度的最佳数据。它们表明,需要在全国范围内采取行动来减轻这一负担,而正确的行动最终几乎肯定会节省成本。