Zebenigus Mehila, Tekle-Haimanot Redda, Worku Dawit K, Thomas Hallie, Steiner Timothy J
Department of Neurology, School of Medicine, College of Health Science, Addis Ababa University, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
Department of Internal Medicine, School of Medicine, College of Health Science, Addis Ababa University, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
J Headache Pain. 2017 Dec;18(1):58. doi: 10.1186/s10194-017-0765-7. Epub 2017 May 25.
Headache disorders are the third-highest cause of disability worldwide, with migraine and medication-overuse headache (MOH) the major contributors. In Ethiopia we have shown these disorders to be highly prevalent: migraine 17.7%, TTH 20.6%, probable MOH (pMOH) 0.7%, any headache yesterday (HY) 6.4%. To inform local health policy, we now estimate disability and other burdens attributable to headache in this country.
In a cross-sectional survey using cluster-randomized sampling, we visited households unannounced in four diverse regions (urban and rural) of Ethiopia. We interviewed one member (18-65 years old) of each household using the HARDSHIP structured questionnaire. Screening and diagnostic questions based on ICHD-II were followed by burden enquiry in multiple domains. We estimated disability using disability weights (DWs) from the Global Burden of Disease 2013 study.
We interviewed 2385 participants (1064 [44.7%] male, 596 [25.0%] urban; participating proportion 99.8%). Reported mean intensity of migraine was 2.6 (scale 1-3). People with migraine spent 11.7% of their time in the ictal state (DW: 0.441); they were therefore 5.2% disabled overall. Pain and disability from TTH were much lower. Mean intensity of pMOH was 2.95. People with pMOH spent 60.2% of time with headache (DW: 0.223), and were 13.4% disabled. Average proportions of per-person lost productive time were, for migraine, 4.5% from paid work, 5.3% from household work; for pMOH they were 29.2% and 16.0%. There were highly-disabled minorities, and large gender differences, males losing more paid workdays, females more household workdays. All headache types were associated with impairments in quality of life. Across the population aged 18-65 years (effectively the working population), disability from headache was 1.4%, with 1.6% of workdays lost (half from migraine). Estimates from HY, eliminating recall error, were highly compatible.
Ethiopia is a low-income country, and cannot afford these losses - including, perhaps, 1.6% of GDP. Political action is necessary, aimed at mitigating both the economic burden and the associated ill health. WHO has recommended structured headache services with their basis in primary care as the most efficient, effective, affordable and equitable solution, potentially cost-saving. We believe they can be implemented within Ethiopia's existing health-care infrastructure.
头痛疾病是全球第三大致残原因,偏头痛和药物过度使用性头痛(MOH)是主要因素。在埃塞俄比亚,我们已表明这些疾病非常普遍:偏头痛患病率为17.7%,紧张型头痛(TTH)为20.6%,可能的药物过度使用性头痛(pMOH)为0.7%,昨日有头痛发作(HY)的比例为6.4%。为了为当地卫生政策提供依据,我们现在估算该国头痛所致的残疾及其他负担。
在一项采用整群随机抽样的横断面调查中,我们在埃塞俄比亚四个不同地区(城市和农村)不事先通知就走访家庭。我们使用HARDSHIP结构化问卷对每户的一名成员(18 - 65岁)进行访谈。基于国际头痛疾病分类第二版(ICHD-II)的筛查和诊断问题之后是多领域的负担询问。我们使用2013年全球疾病负担研究中的残疾权重(DWs)来估算残疾情况。
我们访谈了2385名参与者(1064名[44.7%]男性,596名[25.0%]城市居民;参与比例为99.8%)。报告的偏头痛平均强度为2.6(1 - 3级)。偏头痛患者在发作期花费其11.7%的时间(残疾权重:0.441);因此他们总体残疾率为5.2%。紧张型头痛所致的疼痛和残疾程度要低得多。可能的药物过度使用性头痛的平均强度为2.95。可能的药物过度使用性头痛患者有60.2%的时间处于头痛状态(残疾权重:0.223),残疾率为13.4%。偏头痛患者人均损失的生产时间平均比例为:带薪工作方面为4.5%,家务劳动方面为5.3%;可能的药物过度使用性头痛患者在这两方面分别为29.2%和16.0%。存在残疾程度高的少数群体,且有很大的性别差异,男性损失更多带薪工作日,女性损失更多家务工作日。所有头痛类型均与生活质量受损相关。在18 - 65岁人群(实际上是劳动人口)中,头痛所致残疾率为1.4%,工作日损失率为1.6%(其中一半由偏头痛导致)。消除回忆误差后的昨日有头痛发作情况的估算结果与之高度相符。
埃塞俄比亚是一个低收入国家,无法承受这些损失——可能包括国内生产总值的1.6%。必须采取政治行动,旨在减轻经济负担及相关的健康问题。世界卫生组织推荐以初级保健为基础的结构化头痛服务,认为这是最有效、高效、经济且公平的解决方案,可能节省成本。我们认为它们可在埃塞俄比亚现有的医疗保健基础设施内实施。