Chen Liang, Zhao Lijuan, Alt Frederick W, Krangel Michael S
Department of Immunology, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC 27710.
Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Boston, MA 02115.
J Immunol. 2016 Oct 15;197(8):3188-3197. doi: 10.4049/jimmunol.1601124. Epub 2016 Sep 9.
Chromatin looping mediated by the CCCTC binding factor (CTCF) regulates V(D)J recombination at Ag receptor loci. CTCF-mediated looping can influence recombination signal sequence (RSS) accessibility by regulating enhancer activation of germline promoters. CTCF-mediated looping has also been shown to limit directional tracking of the RAG recombinase along chromatin, and to regulate long-distance interactions between RSSs, independent of the RAG recombinase. However, in all prior instances in which CTCF-mediated looping was shown to influence V(D)J recombination, it was not possible to fully resolve the relative contributions to the V(D)J recombination phenotype of changes in accessibility, RAG tracking, and RAG-independent long-distance interactions. In this study, to assess mechanisms by which CTCF-mediated looping can impact V(D)J recombination, we introduced an ectopic CTCF binding element (CBE) immediately downstream of Eδ in the murine Tcra-Tcrd locus. The ectopic CBE impaired inversional rearrangement of Trdv5 in the absence of measurable effects on Trdv5 transcription and chromatin accessibility. The ectopic CBE also limited directional RAG tracking from the Tcrd recombination center, demonstrating that a single CBE can impact the distribution of RAG proteins along chromatin. However, such tracking cannot account for Trdv5-to-Trdd2 inversional rearrangement. Rather, the defect in Trdv5 rearrangement could only be attributed to a reconfigured chromatin loop organization that limited RAG-independent contacts between the Trdv5 and Trdd2 RSSs. We conclude that CTCF can regulate V(D)J recombination by segregating RSSs into distinct loop domains and inhibiting RSS synapsis, independent of any effects on transcription, RSS accessibility, and RAG tracking.
由CCCTC结合因子(CTCF)介导的染色质环化调节抗原受体基因座处的V(D)J重组。CTCF介导的环化可通过调节种系启动子的增强子激活来影响重组信号序列(RSS)的可及性。CTCF介导的环化还被证明可限制RAG重组酶沿染色质的定向追踪,并调节RSS之间的长距离相互作用,而与RAG重组酶无关。然而,在所有先前显示CTCF介导的环化影响V(D)J重组的实例中,无法完全解析可及性变化、RAG追踪和RAG非依赖性长距离相互作用对V(D)J重组表型的相对贡献。在本研究中,为了评估CTCF介导的环化影响V(D)J重组的机制,我们在小鼠Tcra-Tcrd基因座的Eδ下游立即引入了一个异位CTCF结合元件(CBE)。异位CBE在对Trdv5转录和染色质可及性无明显影响的情况下,损害了Trdv5的倒位重排。异位CBE还限制了从Tcrd重组中心的定向RAG追踪,表明单个CBE可影响RAG蛋白沿染色质的分布。然而,这种追踪不能解释Trdv5到Trdd2的倒位重排。相反,Trdv5重排的缺陷只能归因于染色质环组织的重新配置,该配置限制了Trdv5和Trdd2 RSS之间的RAG非依赖性接触。我们得出结论,CTCF可通过将RSS分隔到不同的环结构域并抑制RSS突触来调节V(D)J重组,而与对转录、RSS可及性和RAG追踪的任何影响无关。