van den Berge M, Wiskerke D, Gerretsen R R R, Tabak J, Sijen T
Netherlands Forensic Institute, P.O. Box 24044, 2490 AA, The Hague, The Netherlands.
InnoGenomics Technologies, 1441 Canal Street, Suite 307, New Orleans, LA, 70112, USA.
Int J Legal Med. 2016 Nov;130(6):1471-1480. doi: 10.1007/s00414-016-1438-9. Epub 2016 Sep 14.
When postmortem intervals (PMIs) increase such as with longer burial times, human remains suffer increasingly from the taphonomic effects of decomposition processes such as autolysis and putrefaction. In this study, various DNA analysis techniques and a messenger RNA (mRNA) profiling method were applied to examine for trends in nucleic acid degradation and the postmortem interval. The DNA analysis techniques include highly sensitive DNA quantitation (with and without degradation index), standard and low template STR profiling, insertion and null alleles (INNUL) of retrotransposable elements typing and mitochondrial DNA profiling. The used mRNA profiling system targets genes with tissue specific expression for seven human organs as reported by Lindenbergh et al. (Int J Legal Med 127:891-900, 27) and has been applied to forensic evidentiary traces but not to excavated tissues. The techniques were applied to a total of 81 brain, lung, liver, skeletal muscle, heart, kidney and skin samples obtained from 19 excavated graves with burial times ranging from 4 to 42 years. Results show that brain and heart are the organs in which both DNA and RNA remain remarkably stable, notwithstanding long PMIs. The other organ tissues either show poor overall profiling results or vary for DNA and RNA profiling success, with sometimes DNA and other times RNA profiling being more successful. No straightforward relations were observed between nucleic acid profiling results and the PMI. This study shows that not only DNA but also RNA molecules can be remarkably stable and used for profiling of long-buried human remains, which corroborate forensic applications. The insight that the brain and heart tissues tend to provide the best profiling results may change sampling policies in identification cases of degrading cadavers.
当死后间隔时间(PMIs)增加时,比如埋葬时间更长,人体遗骸会越来越多地受到自溶和腐败等分解过程的埋藏学影响。在本研究中,应用了各种DNA分析技术和一种信使核糖核酸(mRNA)谱分析方法来检测核酸降解趋势和死后间隔时间。DNA分析技术包括高灵敏度DNA定量分析(有和没有降解指数)、标准和低模板STR谱分析、反转录转座元件的插入和无效等位基因(INNUL)分型以及线粒体DNA谱分析。所使用的mRNA谱分析系统针对Lindenbergh等人(《国际法医学杂志》127:891 - 900,2013年)报道的七种人体器官中具有组织特异性表达的基因,并且已应用于法医证据痕迹,但未应用于挖掘出的组织。这些技术应用于从19个挖掘出的坟墓中获取的总共81份脑、肺、肝、骨骼肌、心脏、肾脏和皮肤样本,埋葬时间从4年到42年不等。结果表明,尽管死后间隔时间很长,但脑和心脏是DNA和RNA都保持显著稳定性的器官。其他器官组织要么总体谱分析结果不佳,要么在DNA和RNA谱分析成功方面存在差异,有时DNA谱分析更成功,有时RNA谱分析更成功。在核酸谱分析结果与死后间隔时间之间未观察到直接关系。本研究表明,不仅DNA分子,而且RNA分子也可以非常稳定,并用于对长期埋葬的人体遗骸进行谱分析,这证实了其在法医方面的应用。脑和心脏组织往往能提供最佳谱分析结果这一见解可能会改变降解尸体身份鉴定案件中的采样策略。