Baux-Cazal L, Gokalsing E, Amadeo S, Messiah A
Centre hospitalier universitaire de La Réunion, 97410 Saint-Pierre, Réunion.
Inserm unité 1178 santé mentale et santé publique, équipe impact du psychotraumatisme et du suicide outre-mer (IPSOM), établissement public de santé mentale de la Réunion, 97460 Saint-Paul, France.
Encephale. 2017 May;43(3):273-280. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2016.05.009. Epub 2016 Sep 13.
Our objective was to review international literature on suicidal behavior prevention for children under age 13.
We gathered all relevant articles on suicide prevention for children under 13. We researched all publications in the French and English languages in PubMed (MEDLINE), PsychINFO and SUDOC databases published until February 2014, with the keywords "child", "child preschool", "prevention and control", "suicide", and "suicide attempted". Publications were included if they described suicidal behavior prevention programs (suicide prevention programs, attempted-suicide prevention programs, suicidal ideation screening programs), and if the studies concerned children under age 13. We also included references cited in the articles if they were not already present in our searches but met inclusion criteria. Studies were excluded if they analyzed populations of children and adolescents without sub-analysis for children under age 13.
A total of 350 potentially relevant articles were identified, 33 of which met the inclusion criteria, including 4 retrieved from articles' bibliography. Preventive measures against suicidal behavior for children under 13 exist and include: social programs, maltreatment prevention, curriculum-based suicide prevention programs, suicide screening in schools, gatekeepers, reduction of access of lethal means of suicide, suicide screening by primary care, and post-suicide intervention programs. Overall, the evidence was limited by methodological concerns, particularly a lack of RCTs. However, positive effects were found: school-based suicide prevention programs and gatekeepers increased knowledge about suicide and how to seek help, post-suicide programs helped to reduce psychological distress in the short term. One study showed a decreased risk of attempted-suicide after entry into the child welfare system.
There are promising interventions but there is not enough scientific evidence to support any efficient preventive measure against suicidal behavior for children under 13, whether primary, secondary, tertiary or post-intervention. More research is needed.
我们的目的是回顾13岁以下儿童自杀行为预防的国际文献。
我们收集了所有关于13岁以下儿童自杀预防的相关文章。我们检索了截至2014年2月在PubMed(MEDLINE)、PsychINFO和SUDOC数据库中发表的法语和英语的所有出版物,关键词为“儿童”、“学龄前儿童”、“预防与控制”、“自杀”和“自杀未遂”。如果出版物描述了自杀行为预防项目(自杀预防项目、自杀未遂预防项目、自杀意念筛查项目),并且研究涉及13岁以下儿童,则将其纳入。如果文章中引用的参考文献不在我们的检索结果中但符合纳入标准,我们也将其纳入。如果研究分析的是儿童和青少年群体,而没有对13岁以下儿童进行亚分析,则将其排除。
共识别出350篇潜在相关文章,其中33篇符合纳入标准,包括从文章参考文献中检索到的4篇。存在针对13岁以下儿童自杀行为的预防措施,包括:社会项目、虐待预防、基于课程的自杀预防项目、学校自杀筛查、守门人、减少自杀致死手段的获取、初级保健中的自杀筛查以及自杀后干预项目。总体而言,证据受到方法学问题的限制,特别是缺乏随机对照试验。然而,发现了积极效果:基于学校的自杀预防项目和守门人增加了关于自杀以及如何寻求帮助的知识,自杀后项目在短期内有助于减轻心理困扰。一项研究表明,进入儿童福利系统后自杀未遂风险降低。
有一些有前景的干预措施,但没有足够的科学证据支持针对13岁以下儿童自杀行为的任何有效预防措施,无论是初级、二级、三级还是干预后措施。需要更多的研究。