Chakhtoura M, Leslie W D, McClung M, Cheung A M, Fuleihan G El-Hajj
Calcium Metabolism and Osteoporosis Program, WHO Collaborating Center for Metabolic Bone Disorders, American University of Beirut Medical Center, P.O. Box: 113-6044/C8, Beirut, Lebanon.
University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Canada.
Osteoporos Int. 2017 Jan;28(1):127-137. doi: 10.1007/s00198-016-3766-5. Epub 2016 Sep 20.
We describe our approach to develop FRAX-based osteoporosis treatment guidelines in Lebanon, a country with low-moderate fracture rates. A hybrid assessment algorithm that combines a fixed 10 % intervention threshold until age 70 years, and an age-dependent threshold thereafter, was deemed most suitable.
The FRAX risk calculator is used to guide intervention thresholds in several national osteoporosis guidelines. This study aimed to describe the approach in developing FRAX-based osteoporosis treatment guidelines in Lebanon, a country with relatively low fracture rates.
We reassessed previous national guidelines combined with an evaluation of age-dependent and fixed FRAX-based intervention threshold models used in the UK, the USA, and Canada. We took into consideration the risk for major osteoporotic fractures (MOF) and the proportions of subjects considered for therapy using such thresholds, before finalizing a model for Lebanon.
The new Lebanese guidelines retained the recommendation to treat individuals with fragility fracture at the hip or spine. A femoral neck T-score ≤-2.5 in subjects without fractures was dropped, since it would imply consideration of therapy for individuals with a 10-year risk for MOF of <10 %, up to age 75 years in women. After considering the impact of both age-dependent and fixed intervention thresholds, we chose a new hybrid algorithm, combining a fixed 10 % treatment threshold until age 70 years and an age-dependent threshold thereafter.
The Lebanese FRAX-based hybrid model takes into consideration the risk for MOF and the proportions of subjects considered for treatment. This model avoids consideration of drug therapy in a large proportion of younger subjects at low risk for fracture and targets high risk elderly individuals. It was deemed most suitable for Lebanon and may be an option for other countries with relatively low fracture rates.
我们描述了在黎巴嫩制定基于FRAX的骨质疏松症治疗指南的方法,黎巴嫩是一个骨折率处于中低水平的国家。一种混合评估算法被认为是最合适的,该算法在70岁之前采用固定的10%干预阈值,之后采用与年龄相关的阈值。
FRAX风险计算器被用于指导多个国家骨质疏松症指南中的干预阈值。本研究旨在描述在黎巴嫩这个骨折率相对较低的国家制定基于FRAX的骨质疏松症治疗指南的方法。
我们重新评估了先前的国家指南,并结合对英国、美国和加拿大使用的与年龄相关和基于FRAX的固定干预阈值模型的评估。在确定黎巴嫩的模型之前,我们考虑了主要骨质疏松性骨折(MOF)的风险以及使用此类阈值考虑治疗的受试者比例。
新的黎巴嫩指南保留了对髋部或脊柱脆性骨折患者进行治疗的建议。对于无骨折的受试者,股骨颈T值≤-2.5的标准被放弃,因为这将意味着要考虑对10年内MOF风险<10%的个体进行治疗,女性最高至75岁。在考虑了与年龄相关和固定干预阈值的影响后,我们选择了一种新的混合算法,在70岁之前采用固定的10%治疗阈值,之后采用与年龄相关的阈值。
黎巴嫩基于FRAX的混合模型考虑了MOF风险和考虑治疗的受试者比例。该模型避免了在很大一部分骨折风险较低的年轻受试者中考虑药物治疗,并针对高风险的老年个体。它被认为最适合黎巴嫩,也可能是其他骨折率相对较低的国家的一个选择。