Inglis Tom, Schouten Rowan, Dalzell Kristian, Evison Jeremy, Inglis Grahame
Orthopaedic Trainee, Orthopaedic Department, Christchurch and Burwood Hospitals, Canterbury District Health Board, Christchurch.
Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon, Orthopaedic Department, Christchurch and Burwood Hospitals, Canterbury District Health Board, Christchurch.
N Z Med J. 2016 Sep 23;129(1442):19-24.
The aim of this project was to determine the unmet need within the public health system for patients referred for elective Orthopaedic Specialist Spinal assessment and treatment in the Canterbury District Health Board (CDHB) region.
Between January 2014 and January 2015 data was collected from all elective referrals to the CDHB Orthopaedic Spinal Service. During this period, the number of available outpatient appointments was set by the CDHB. Within this clinical capacity, patients were triaged by the four consultant surgeons into those of most need based on the referral letter and available radiological imaging. Those unable to be provided with a clinical appointment were discharged back to their GP for ongoing conservative care. Of those patients that received specialist assessment and were considered in need of elective surgical intervention, a proportion were denied treatment if the surgery was unable to be performed within the government determined four-month waiting time threshold.
During the study period, 707 patients were referred to the CDHB orthopaedic spinal team for elective specialist assessment. Of these, 522 (74%) were declined an outpatient appointment due to a lack of available clinical time. Of the 185 patients given a specialist assessment, 158 (85%) were recommended for elective surgery. Ninety-one (58%) were denied surgery and referred back for ongoing GP care due to unavailable operating capacity within the four-month waiting list threshold. Within this group of 91 patients, 16 patients were declined on multiple occasions (14 patients twice and two patients on three occasions).
This study quantifies the unmet need for both Spinal Orthopaedic Specialist assessment and, if warranted, surgical management of elective spine conditions within the Canterbury public health system. It highlights the degree of rationing within the public health system and its failure to adequately provide for the Canterbury Public.
本项目旨在确定坎特伯雷地区卫生委员会(CDHB)区域内,因择期接受骨科专家脊柱评估和治疗而被转诊的患者在公共卫生系统中未得到满足的需求。
2014年1月至2015年1月期间,收集了所有转诊至CDHB骨科脊柱服务部门的择期转诊数据。在此期间,CDHB设定了可用门诊预约的数量。在这一临床能力范围内,四名顾问外科医生根据转诊信和可用的放射影像,将患者分类为最需要治疗的患者。那些无法获得临床预约的患者被转回其全科医生处接受持续的保守治疗。在那些接受了专家评估并被认为需要择期手术干预的患者中,如果手术无法在政府规定的四个月等待时间阈值内进行,一部分患者将被拒绝治疗。
在研究期间,707名患者被转诊至CDHB骨科脊柱团队进行择期专家评估。其中,522名(74%)患者因缺乏可用临床时间而未获得门诊预约。在185名接受专家评估的患者中,158名(85%)被建议进行择期手术。91名(58%)患者因在四个月等待名单阈值内无法获得手术能力而被拒绝手术,并被转回接受全科医生的持续治疗。在这91名患者中,16名患者多次被拒绝(14名患者被拒绝两次,两名患者被拒绝三次)。
本研究量化了坎特伯雷公共卫生系统中脊柱骨科专家评估以及必要时对择期脊柱疾病进行手术管理方面未得到满足的需求。它突出了公共卫生系统内的配给程度及其未能充分满足坎特伯雷公众需求这一情况。