Murata Nozomu, Murata Kiyoko, Gonzalez-Cuyar Luis F, Maravilla Kenneth R
Magn Reson Imaging. 2016 Dec;34(10):1359-1365. doi: 10.1016/j.mri.2016.08.025. Epub 2016 Oct 5.
Until recognition of the association of nephrogenic systemic fibrosis (NSF) and gadolinium based contrast agents (GBCA) in 2006, these agents were considered extremely safe and without major adverse effects. Even after the recognition of NSF, most physicians considered all GBCAs to be safe when used in patients with normal renal function. This belief has been called into question with the discovery by Kanda in 2014 that gadolinium (Gd) is deposited in brain tissue in patients with normal kidney function. Since that initial report, there have been a number of important studies analyzing the effects of various GBCAs in brain using MR T1 signal intensity measurements and postmortem tissue analyses with inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. From these our knowledge and understanding of some key issues surrounding these observations has rapidly evolved. This report reviews and summarizes many recent human and animal studies in combination with past studies to better understand Gd tissue deposition not only in brain but also in bone and skin. Brain tissue deposition was initially demonstrated to occur with less stable group 1 linear agents but recent postmortem studies now confirm that Gd deposition also occurs with more stable linear agents as well as with macrocyclic agents although at much lower levels. Although no adverse health effects have been documented to date, even for the group 1 agents that deposit Gd in higher amounts, the implications for possible unrecognized toxicity is discussed. Future studies are being pursued that may provide better understanding of the various chemical forms of Gd that are deposited in tissues. This may help elucidate relative risks of different types of agents, mechanisms involved and even recognition of potential downstream toxic effects.
在2006年认识到肾源性系统性纤维化(NSF)与钆基造影剂(GBCA)之间的关联之前,这些造影剂被认为极其安全且无重大不良反应。即使在认识到NSF之后,大多数医生仍认为所有GBCA在肾功能正常的患者中使用时都是安全的。2014年神田发现钆(Gd)会在肾功能正常的患者脑组织中沉积,这一观点受到了质疑。自该初步报告以来,已有多项重要研究通过磁共振T1信号强度测量以及使用电感耦合等离子体质谱的尸检组织分析来分析各种GBCA对脑的影响。基于这些研究,我们对围绕这些观察结果的一些关键问题的认识和理解迅速发展。本报告回顾并总结了许多近期的人体和动物研究,并结合过去的研究,以更好地了解Gd在组织中的沉积情况,不仅包括脑,还包括骨和皮肤。脑组织沉积最初被证明发生在稳定性较差的第1组线性造影剂中,但最近的尸检研究现在证实,Gd沉积也发生在更稳定的线性造影剂以及大环造影剂中,尽管水平要低得多。尽管迄今为止尚未记录到对健康的不良影响,即使对于Gd沉积量较高的第1组造影剂,也讨论了可能存在未被认识到的毒性的影响。目前正在进行未来研究,可能会更好地了解沉积在组织中的Gd的各种化学形式。这可能有助于阐明不同类型造影剂的相对风险、涉及的机制,甚至识别潜在的下游毒性作用。