Williams J R
Center for Bioethics, Clinical Research Institute of Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
J Med Philos. 1989 Aug;14(4):425-44. doi: 10.1093/jmp/14.4.425.
Canadians frequently have recourse to public commissions as a means of dealing with contentious public policy issues. This essay examines the role of philosophers and philosophy in nine such commissions, all of which have dealt with issues in biomedical ethics. The principal findings of this essay are that philosophers have not been used extensively by these commissions, and that the philosophical aspects of the issues under investigation have been dealth with quite inadequately. The essay concludes with suggestions for an expanded role for philosophers in such commissions.
加拿大人经常求助于公共委员会,将其作为处理有争议的公共政策问题的一种方式。本文考察了哲学家和哲学在九个这样的委员会中的作用,所有这些委员会都处理过生物医学伦理问题。本文的主要发现是,这些委员会并未广泛利用哲学家,而且所调查问题的哲学层面也未得到充分处理。本文最后针对哲学家在这类委员会中发挥更大作用提出了建议。