Templeton Michelle, Lohan Maria, Kelly Carmel, Lundy Laura
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Queen's University Belfast, UK.
School of Social Sciences, Education and Social Work, Queen's University Belfast, UK.
J Adv Nurs. 2017 Jun;73(6):1288-1301. doi: 10.1111/jan.13207. Epub 2016 Dec 1.
The aim of this study was to synthesize the qualitative evidence investigating adolescents' views on heterosexual readiness.
Adolescents' understandings of sexual readiness are often missing in research and debates on sexual health and related concepts like sexual consent. Research to date has predominantly focussed on age and socio-cultural predictors of sexual debut, thus failing to explain how adolescents themselves conceptualize their readiness for heterosexual relations.
A systematic review and thematic synthesis of qualitative evidence.
CINAHL, Psychinfo, PubMed, Web of science were searched, 1985-Feb 2016.
Critical Appraisal Skills Programme checklist was used to assess methodological quality. A thematic synthesis focused on commonalities and variations in the data from included studies on adolescents' perspectives of their readiness for sex.
Sixteen studies were included. Themes identified were: social learning, relationships and implications for sexual health promotion and practice.
Adolescents may not view initiating sex as problematic, focusing instead on the rewards sex brings and less on health concerns. Adolescents tend to reproduce dominant gender norms of masculinity and femininity in communication about sexual decision-making, which are sometimes influenced by social scripts of career aspirations and ethnic identity. Age was also significant in adolescents' accounts. Early adolescence is a critical period when understandings of gender equality become embedded, thus an opportunity to engage adolescents in critiquing ideas about gender equality and sexual rights. Further research exploring adolescents' understandings of sexual readiness is required. We recommend a participatory approach to support the inclusion of adolescent voices to inform contextually relevant sexual health promotion strategies.
本研究旨在综合定性证据,调查青少年对异性恋准备状态的看法。
在关于性健康及性同意等相关概念的研究和辩论中,常常缺失青少年对性准备状态的理解。迄今为止的研究主要集中在首次性行为的年龄和社会文化预测因素上,因此未能解释青少年自身如何将他们对异性恋关系的准备状态概念化。
对定性证据进行系统综述和主题综合分析。
检索了1985年至2016年2月期间的CINAHL、Psychinfo、PubMed、科学网。
使用批判性评估技能计划清单来评估方法学质量。主题综合分析聚焦于纳入研究中关于青少年对性准备状态看法的数据中的共性和差异。
纳入了16项研究。确定的主题有:社会学习、人际关系以及对性健康促进和实践的影响。
青少年可能不认为开始性行为有问题,而是更关注性行为带来的回报,较少关注健康问题。青少年在关于性决策的交流中往往会重现男性气质和女性气质的主导性别规范,这有时会受到职业抱负和种族身份的社会脚本的影响。年龄在青少年的描述中也很重要。青春期早期是性别平等观念得以确立的关键时期,因此是让青少年参与批判性别平等和性权利观念的一个契机。需要进一步研究探索青少年对性准备状态的理解。我们建议采用参与式方法,以支持纳入青少年的声音来为因地制宜的性健康促进策略提供信息。