Schmid G P, Matheny L C, Zaidi A A, Kraus S J
Division of Sexually Transmitted Diseases, Centers for Disease Control, Atlanta, Georgia 30333.
J Clin Microbiol. 1989 Jun;27(6):1230-3. doi: 10.1128/jcm.27.6.1230-1233.1989.
Many media have been formulated for the growth of Trichomonas vaginalis, but the relative sensitivities of these media have not been determined. We evaluated the ability of six media, including all five media commercially available in the United States, to grow Trichomonas vaginalis from vaginal secretions. In a first experiment, we evaluated the ability of five media to grow T. vaginalis from vaginal secretions of 375 women and determined the optimal days on which to read culture tubes, by inoculating aliquots of secretions into each medium and reading the tubes 1, 2, 3, 4, and 7 days later. Sixty-five patients (17%) had a positive wet-mount examination for T. vaginalis, and all the positive results were confirmed by growth in at least one medium. Of 310 wet-mount-negative specimens, 37 (12%) grew T. vaginalis; overall, 102 women (27%) had a positive culture. Diamond and modified Diamond media (the latter being the only medium not commercially available) detected 99 (97%) and 92 (90%) isolates, respectively, compared with three formulations of Kupferberg medium, which detected 77 (75%), 50 (49%), and 43 (42%) isolates. The optimal single day to read wet-mount-negative cultures was day 7, but 4 (11%) of the 37 positive specimens were positive only before day 7. In a second study, we compared the ability of modified Diamond medium with that of a sixth medium, Lash medium, to grow T. vaginalis from 48 wet-mount-positive specimens; modified Diamond medium supported growth in all cases, whereas Lash medium supported growth in only 26 (54%) cases. We conclude that formulations of Diamond medium are superior to formulations of Kupferberg or Lash medium for growth of t. vaginalis.
许多培养基已被配制用于阴道毛滴虫的生长,但这些培养基的相对敏感性尚未确定。我们评估了六种培养基(包括美国市面上所有五种商业化培养基)从阴道分泌物中培养阴道毛滴虫的能力。在第一个实验中,我们通过将分泌物等分试样接种到每种培养基中,并在1、2、3、4和7天后读取培养管,评估了五种培养基从375名女性的阴道分泌物中培养阴道毛滴虫的能力,并确定了读取培养管的最佳天数。65名患者(17%)阴道毛滴虫湿片检查呈阳性,所有阳性结果均通过至少一种培养基中的生长得到证实。在310份湿片阴性标本中,37份(12%)培养出阴道毛滴虫;总体而言,102名女性(27%)培养结果呈阳性。钻石培养基和改良钻石培养基(后者是唯一非商业化的培养基)分别检测到99株(97%)和92株(90%)分离株,相比之下,三种库普费尔贝格培养基配方分别检测到77株(75%)、50株(49%)和43株(42%)分离株。读取湿片阴性培养物的最佳单日是第7天,但37份阳性标本中有4份(11%)仅在第7天之前呈阳性。在第二项研究中,我们比较了改良钻石培养基与第六种培养基拉什培养基从48份湿片阳性标本中培养阴道毛滴虫的能力;改良钻石培养基在所有情况下都支持生长,而拉什培养基仅在26例(54%)情况下支持生长。我们得出结论,对于阴道毛滴虫的生长,钻石培养基配方优于库普费尔贝格或拉什培养基配方。