Rafai Nicole, Lemos Martin, Kennes Lieven Nils, Hawari Ayichah, Gerhardt-Szép Susanne, Classen-Linke Irmgard
Department of Prosthodontics and Biomaterials, Center for Implantology, Medical Faculty, RWTH Aachen University, Pauwelsstrasse 30, Aachen, 52074, Germany.
Present address: Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Medical Faculty, RWTH Aachen University, Pauwelsstrasse 30, Aachen, 52074, Germany.
BMC Med Educ. 2016 Nov 25;16(1):305. doi: 10.1186/s12909-016-0825-8.
Establishing a strong link early on between preclinical coursework and the clinical context is necessary for students to be able to recognize the practical relevance of the curriculum during their preclinical anatomical courses and to transfer knowledge more easily. Our objective was to enhance the clinical relevance of a preclinical anatomy course for second-year medical students of dentistry by implementing an interdisciplinary skills training course on "Palpation of the Head and Neck Muscles" and to measure the learning outcomes.
For the curricular development of the expanded course module, Kern's 6-step approach was applied including subjective evaluation. We used a peer-teaching format supported by an e-learning application. A randomized control study measured effects of the two components (skills training, e-module) on learning outcomes. Four learning methods were compared: (1) lecture, (2) lecture + e-module, (3) lecture + skills training, (4) lecture + skills training + e-module. An objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) was used to measure and compare learning outcomes.
The two-way variance analysis demonstrated that participation in the skills training had a statistically significant effect on the OSCE results (p = 0.0007). Students who participated in the skills training did better (φ 107.4 ± 14.4 points) than students who only attended the lecture (φ 88.8 ± 26.2 points). Students who used the e-module but did not attend the skills training earned a slightly but not significantly higher average number of points (φ 91.8 ± 31.3 points) than those who only attended the lecture. The learning outcomes of the skills training were again significantly increased when the training was combined with the e-module (φ 121.8 ± 21.8 points), thus making it the ideal method for achieving the learning objectives defined in this study.
The "Palpation of the Head and Neck Muscles" interdisciplinary skills training course linking basic anatomical knowledge and clinical skills led to clearly improved learning outcomes for both, anatomical knowledge and clinical skills. The additional use of an e-learning tool (e-module) improved the learning effect.
在临床前课程与临床环境之间尽早建立紧密联系,对于学生在临床前解剖课程中认识课程的实际相关性并更轻松地迁移知识至关重要。我们的目标是通过实施“头颈部肌肉触诊”跨学科技能培训课程,增强牙科专业二年级医学生临床前解剖课程的临床相关性,并衡量学习成果。
对于扩展课程模块的课程开发,应用了 Kern 的六步方法,包括主观评估。我们采用了由电子学习应用程序支持的同伴教学形式。一项随机对照研究测量了两个组成部分(技能培训、电子模块)对学习成果的影响。比较了四种学习方法:(1)讲座,(2)讲座 + 电子模块,(3)讲座 + 技能培训,(4)讲座 + 技能培训 + 电子模块。使用客观结构化临床考试(OSCE)来测量和比较学习成果。
双向方差分析表明,参与技能培训对 OSCE 结果有统计学显著影响(p = 0.0007)。参与技能培训的学生表现更好(平均成绩为107.4 ± 14.4分),优于仅参加讲座的学生(平均成绩为88.8 ± 26.2分)。使用电子模块但未参加技能培训的学生平均得分略高(平均成绩为91.8 ± 31.3分),但与仅参加讲座的学生相比无显著差异。当技能培训与电子模块相结合时,学习成果再次显著提高(平均成绩为121.8 ± 21.8分),因此使其成为实现本研究中定义的学习目标的理想方法。
“头颈部肌肉触诊”跨学科技能培训课程将基础解剖知识与临床技能相联系,使解剖知识和临床技能的学习成果均得到明显改善。额外使用电子学习工具(电子模块)提高了学习效果。