Gasnier M, Pelissolo A, Bondolfi G, Pelissolo S, Tomba M, Mallet L, N'diaye K
Centre hospitalier Sainte-Anne, service hospitalo-universitaire, 1, rue Cabanis, 75014 Paris, France.
IMRB Inserm U955, fondation, service de psychiatrie sectorisée et DHU PePsy, hôpitaux, universitaires Henri-Mondor, AP-HP, université Paris-Est Créteil, FondaMental, 94000 Créteil, France.
Encephale. 2017 Dec;43(6):594-599. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2016.10.004. Epub 2016 Nov 22.
Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) is a frequent and severe disease, potentially inducing a major impairment for the patient and burden for their family. Recent research in psychiatry and neuroscience have led to better comprehension of the disease's mechanisms and helped to improve its treatment. However, a large proportion of patients have refractory symptoms, including for traditional cognitive and behavioral therapy by exposure and response prevention (ERP), leading clinicians to look for new treatments. Mindfulness-based interventions (MBI) are a new type of approach, initially based on Buddhist meditation, which aims to provide better consciousness of the present moment. It has been successfully developed in some psychiatric diseases and other general medical conditions such as chronic pain. The two main programs using mindfulness meditation, Mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) and Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT), have shown effectiveness for the reduction of depressive and anxiety symptoms and relapses of depressive episodes in unipolar depression. It has no side effects and is well tolerated by patients. Its action relies on the specific correction of cognitive deficits in attention, emotion regulation and executive functions which are shared by OCD, GAD and depression. For OCD, we make the hypothesis that Mindfulness-Based Interventions could reduce the cognitive bias specifically existing in this pathology, such as dysfunctional beliefs, and therefore improve the symptoms. This article first reviews the existing literature on clinical trials involving Mindfulness-Based Interventions in OCD which comprises a small number of clinical studies based on very different types of protocols. At this time, and due to the lack of gold-standard studies with a large number of patients, no proof of the efficiency of mindfulness-based interventions in OCD has been shown. In a second section, following our hypothesis on the mechanisms of specific and non-specific action of this therapy in OCD, we propose a cognitive model of mindfulness-based therapy action in OCD involving the correction of OCD's cognitive bias. In this model, mindfulness-based therapy is supposed to treat specifically the cognitive aspects of the disease, while ERP is focused on its behavioral part. Then we present a clinical study aiming to prove the feasibility and the interest of the use of mindfulness in OCD, carried out in two different clinical centers. One of them used MBCT while the second used MBSR. Its results show the feasibility of mindfulness-based therapy in OCD patients and tend to prove that it could be more effective in young patients suffering from less severe forms of OCD. In parallel, attention tests and fMRI scans were done at the beginning and at the end of the therapy. Their results will be published separately. We also discuss the putative role of a specific form of MBCT adapted for OCD, specifically for its benefits in psychoeducation, which could reduce the dysfunctional beliefs present in OCD patients. Finally, we propose a therapeutic strategy in which the MBCT could complement the classical ERP therapy, as a "maintenance" treatment, aiming to extend the relapse of OCD symptoms. This article is a step further in the use of mindfulness-based therapy for OCD which could be added to the existing treatments reducing the patient's symptoms and improving their quality of life.
强迫症(OCD)是一种常见且严重的疾病,可能给患者带来重大损害,并给其家庭造成负担。精神病学和神经科学领域的最新研究有助于更好地理解该疾病的机制,并推动其治疗方法的改进。然而,很大一部分患者存在难治性症状,包括对传统的认知行为疗法(暴露与反应阻止法,ERP)也有抵抗,这促使临床医生寻求新的治疗方法。基于正念的干预措施(MBI)是一种新型方法,最初基于佛教冥想,旨在提升对当下时刻的觉察。它已在一些精神疾病以及其他普通医疗状况(如慢性疼痛)中成功应用。两种主要的正念冥想项目,即基于正念的减压疗法(MBSR)和基于正念的认知疗法(MBCT),已显示出在减轻单相抑郁症的抑郁和焦虑症状以及预防抑郁发作复发方面的有效性。它没有副作用,患者耐受性良好。其作用依赖于对注意力、情绪调节和执行功能等认知缺陷的特定纠正,这些认知缺陷在强迫症、广泛性焦虑症和抑郁症中都存在。对于强迫症,我们提出假设,基于正念的干预措施可以减少该病症中特有的认知偏差,如功能失调性信念,从而改善症状。本文首先回顾了现有关于强迫症中基于正念干预措施的临床试验文献,其中包括少量基于非常不同类型方案的临床研究。目前,由于缺乏大量患者参与的金标准研究,尚未证明基于正念的干预措施对强迫症有效。在第二部分,根据我们对该疗法在强迫症中特定和非特定作用机制的假设,我们提出了一个基于正念疗法在强迫症中作用的认知模型,该模型涉及纠正强迫症的认知偏差。在这个模型中,基于正念的疗法被认为专门针对疾病的认知方面进行治疗,而ERP则专注于其行为部分。然后我们介绍一项旨在证明在强迫症中使用正念的可行性和价值的临床研究,该研究在两个不同的临床中心开展。其中一个中心使用MBCT,另一个使用MBSR。研究结果表明基于正念的疗法在强迫症患者中具有可行性,并倾向于证明它在患有较轻形式强迫症的年轻患者中可能更有效。同时,在治疗开始和结束时进行了注意力测试和功能磁共振成像扫描。其结果将另行发表。我们还讨论了一种专门为强迫症改编的MBCT的假定作用,特别是其在心理教育方面的益处,这可能减少强迫症患者中存在的功能失调性信念。最后,我们提出一种治疗策略,其中MBCT可以作为一种“维持”治疗来补充经典的ERP疗法,旨在延长强迫症症状的复发间隔。本文在将基于正念的疗法用于强迫症方面又迈进了一步,它可以添加到现有的治疗方法中,减轻患者症状并提高其生活质量。