Kindell Jacqueline, Keady John, Sage Karen, Wilkinson Ray
Pennine Care NHS Foundation Trust, Stockport, UK, Offerton, UK.
School of Nursing, Midwifery and Social Work/Greater Manchester West Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2017 Jul;52(4):392-406. doi: 10.1111/1460-6984.12298. Epub 2016 Nov 27.
There has been increasing interest in dementia care in recent years, including how practitioners, service providers and society in general can help individuals to live well with the condition. An important aspect to this is provision of advice to ensure conversation partners effectively support the person with dementia in conversation.
To provide a descriptive review of the literature examining everyday conversation in dementia in order to inform practice and research.
METHODS & PROCEDURES: This review used a method specifically developed for reviewing conversation analytic and related literature. A range of databases were searched using key words and explicitly described inclusion criteria leading to a final corpus of 50 titles. Using this qualitative methodology, each paper was examined and data extracted. The contribution of each of these is described and the implications for practice and research are outlined.
This review examined studies into conversation in Alzheimer's disease, vascular dementia and Lewy body dementia, grouping these into: early influential studies; work drawing on positioning theory; studies using social and linguistic approaches; collaborative storytelling; formulaic language; studies specifically using conversation analysis; and conversation as a target for individualized therapy. In addition, more recent work examining primary progressive aphasia and behavioural variant frontotemporal dementia was explored. Overall, this review indicates that research examining conversation in natural settings provides a rich source of data to explore not just the challenges within conversation for those taking part, but also the skills retained by the person with dementia. An important aspect of this understanding is the notion that these skills relate not only to information exchange but also aspects of social interaction. The role of others in scaffolding the conversation abilities of the person with dementia and the potential of this for developing interventions are discussed.
CONCLUSIONS & IMPLICATIONS: The review indicates that interventions targeting conversation in dementia are often advocated in the literature but currently such approaches remain to be systematically evaluated. In addition, many of the important insights arising from these studies have yet to inform multidisciplinary dementia care practice.
近年来,人们对痴呆症护理的兴趣与日俱增,其中包括从业者、服务提供者和整个社会如何帮助患者更好地应对这一病症。其中一个重要方面是提供建议,以确保对话伙伴在交谈中有效支持痴呆症患者。
对有关痴呆症日常对话的文献进行描述性综述,为实践和研究提供参考。
本综述采用了专门为综述会话分析及相关文献而开发的方法。通过关键词搜索一系列数据库,并明确描述纳入标准,最终形成了一个包含50篇文献的语料库。采用这种定性方法,对每篇论文进行审查并提取数据。描述了每篇文献的贡献,并概述了其对实践和研究的启示。
本综述考察了针对阿尔茨海默病、血管性痴呆和路易体痴呆患者对话的研究,并将其分为:早期有影响力的研究;基于定位理论的研究;使用社会和语言方法的研究;合作叙事;公式化语言;专门使用会话分析的研究;以及将对话作为个体化治疗目标的研究。此外,还探讨了近期有关原发性进行性失语和行为变异型额颞叶痴呆的研究。总体而言,本综述表明,对自然环境中对话的研究提供了丰富的数据来源,不仅可以探索参与对话者面临的挑战,还能了解痴呆症患者保留的技能。这种理解的一个重要方面是,这些技能不仅与信息交流有关,还与社会互动的各个方面有关。讨论了他人在支撑痴呆症患者对话能力方面的作用及其在开发干预措施方面的潜力。
综述表明,文献中经常提倡针对痴呆症患者对话的干预措施,但目前此类方法仍有待系统评估。此外,这些研究产生的许多重要见解尚未应用于多学科痴呆症护理实践。