Benfield D G, Leib S A, Vollman J H
Pediatrics. 1978 Aug;62(2):171-7.
We determined the grief response to neonatal death of 50 mother-father pairs by administering a questionnaire and conducting a semistructured interview during the infant postmortem review. As measured by a parent grief score, maternal grief significantly exceeded paternal grief (t = 5.89, P less than .0001). Parent grief was not significantly related to birth weight, duration of life, extent of parent-infant contact, previous perinatal loss, parent age, or distance from the hospital of birth to the regional center (Pearson product-moment correlation coefficients). However, the attitudes and behavior of family, friends, and health care personnel in the hospital of birth often adversely influenced parent grieving. Of 39 mother-father pairs whose infants required respirator support, 18 participated in a group decision with their physician to withdraw respirator support when the prospects of infant survival seemed hopeless (limited respirator care group). No significant differences in parent grief scores were found (t tests) when the limited respirator care group was compared to those parents of infants who died despite uninterrupted respirator care. Our data suggest that informed parents can participate as partners with their physician in difficult infant care decision, even when death results, and adjust to their loss with healthy grieving.
我们通过在婴儿尸检复查期间发放问卷并进行半结构化访谈,确定了50对父母对新生儿死亡的悲伤反应。根据父母悲伤评分,母亲的悲伤程度显著超过父亲(t = 5.89,P < .0001)。父母的悲伤与出生体重、存活时间、母婴接触程度、既往围产期损失、父母年龄或出生地医院到地区中心的距离均无显著相关性(皮尔逊积差相关系数)。然而,出生地医院的家人、朋友和医护人员的态度及行为常常对父母的悲伤产生不利影响。在39对其婴儿需要呼吸机支持的父母中,当婴儿存活希望渺茫时,18对与医生共同参与了撤掉呼吸机支持的集体决策(有限呼吸机护理组)。将有限呼吸机护理组与那些婴儿尽管接受了不间断呼吸机护理仍死亡的父母进行比较时,未发现父母悲伤评分有显著差异(t检验)。我们的数据表明,即使导致了死亡,了解情况的父母也可以作为医生的合作伙伴参与艰难的婴儿护理决策,并通过健康的悲伤过程来适应丧子之痛。