Seecharan Grace A, Andresen Elena M, Norris Kaye, Toce Suzanne S
Department of Community Health, School of Public Health, Saint Louis University, St Louis, MO, USA.
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2004 Jun;158(6):515-20. doi: 10.1001/archpedi.158.6.515.
Deaths among children are rare, but the effect on family members is profound. Compared with adult deaths, information about grief, recovery, and quality of care is sparse.
To describe aspects of bereavement for parents who had experienced the death of a child and to compare these aspects by parent sex, type of death, and overall experience.
In-person interviews with families, primarily parents, a mean of 21.8 months after the child's death.
Academic, tertiary care, faith-based children's hospital.
Fifty-nine child deaths and 79 parents or guardians.
In-person interviews, including standard instruments for bereavement and quality of care: the Texas Revised Inventory of Grief and the Comprehensive Assessment of Satisfaction With Care-Short Form.
Fathers and mothers had similar levels of grief. Mothers who experienced the sudden death of their child had somewhat more intense grief reactions than those whose child died of a chronic condition. Grief scores did not vary according to satisfaction with treatment. Comprehensive Assessment of Satisfaction With Care-Short Form scores were high for parents and similar between mothers and fathers and between sudden and unexpected deaths.
Although there were some differences in grief responses among parents, satisfaction-with-care scores were high. Further studies should examine the role of satisfaction with care in parental grief response and incorporate the reporting of experiences rather than simple ratings to measure satisfaction with care.
儿童死亡较为罕见,但对家庭成员的影响却极为深远。与成人死亡相比,关于悲伤、恢复及护理质量的信息较为匮乏。
描述经历过孩子死亡的父母的丧亲之痛的各个方面,并按父母性别、死亡类型及总体经历对这些方面进行比较。
在孩子死亡平均21.8个月后对家庭(主要是父母)进行面对面访谈。
学术性、三级护理、基于信仰的儿童医院。
59例儿童死亡及79名父母或监护人。
面对面访谈,包括丧亲之痛及护理质量的标准工具:《德克萨斯修订悲伤量表》和《护理满意度综合评估简表》。
父亲和母亲的悲伤程度相似。孩子突然死亡的母亲比孩子死于慢性病的母亲悲伤反应更强烈一些。悲伤得分并未因对治疗的满意度而有所不同。父母的《护理满意度综合评估简表》得分较高,且母亲与父亲之间、突然死亡与意外死亡之间得分相似。
尽管父母的悲伤反应存在一些差异,但护理满意度得分较高。进一步的研究应考察护理满意度在父母悲伤反应中的作用,并纳入经历的报告而非简单的评分来衡量护理满意度。