Wu San-Yuan, Chen Huey-Yi, Tsai Kao-Sung, Chiang Jen-Huai, Muo Chih-Hsin, Sung Fung-Chang, Chen Yung-Hsiang, Chen Wen-Chi
China Medical University, Taichung, Taiwan.
Hungkuang University, Taichung, Taiwan.
Inquiry. 2016 Dec 7;53. doi: 10.1177/0046958016681148. Print 2016.
Traditional Chinese herbal medicine (CHM), which is widely used to treat pain and urolithiasis, is a promising therapy for urinary stone prevention. This study investigated the clinical efficacy of a popular CHM, Wu-Ling-San (WLS), in Taiwan for the prophylaxis of recurrent nephrolithiasis as assessed by surgical stone treatment via a nationwide population-based cohort study. The National Health Insurance Research Database, 2000-2010, which included one million patient records. All patients diagnosed with stone disease at the beginning of the study. The matched controls (4-fold the number of WLS patients) were stone patients who did not take WLS. Data analysis included the stone surgeries following the first treatment. We enrolled 11 900 patients with stone disease, and the incidence of stone patients in this database was 1.19%. The prevalence of comorbidities such as benign prostate hyperplasia, chronic kidney disease, diabetes mellitus, and urinary tract infection, but not hypertension, was significantly higher in WLS users. Several patients in both groups were prescribed potassium citrate. The stone treatment rate was significantly higher in WLS users (17.85%) than in the non-WLS users (14.47%). WLS users with an associated comorbidity had a higher treatment rate than the non-WLS users: 21.05% versus 16.70%, respectively. The surgery rate for upper urinary tract stones was higher in WLS users than in the non-WLS users (adjusted hazard ratio, 1.28; 95% confidence interval, 1.08-1.52; P < .05). The stone treatment rate (52.79%) was significantly higher in patients who used a very high amount of WLS (adjusted hazard ratio, 3.02; 95% confidence interval, 2.30-3.98). Stone patients using a high amount of WLS use had a high stone surgical rate. Long-term therapy with WLS did not have a preventive effect on stone surgical treatment. Long-term potassium citrate therapy as a preventive measure appeared to be underutilized in this study.
传统中药(CHM)被广泛用于治疗疼痛和尿石症,是预防尿路结石的一种有前景的疗法。本研究通过一项基于全国人群的队列研究,调查了台湾一种常用中药五苓散(WLS)预防复发性肾结石的临床疗效,该疗效通过手术结石治疗进行评估。使用了2000年至2010年的国民健康保险研究数据库,其中包含100万份患者记录。所有患者在研究开始时被诊断患有结石病。匹配的对照组(WLS患者数量的4倍)是未服用WLS的结石患者。数据分析包括首次治疗后的结石手术情况。我们纳入了11900例结石病患者,该数据库中结石患者的发病率为1.19%。WLS使用者中良性前列腺增生、慢性肾病、糖尿病和尿路感染等合并症的患病率显著高于高血压,但高血压患病率无显著差异。两组中均有几名患者被开了柠檬酸钾。WLS使用者的结石治疗率(17.85%)显著高于未使用WLS的患者(14.47%)。伴有合并症的WLS使用者的治疗率高于未使用WLS的患者:分别为21.05%和16.70%。WLS使用者上尿路结石的手术率高于未使用WLS的患者(调整后的风险比为1.28;95%置信区间为1.08 - 1.52;P < 0.05)。使用大量WLS的患者的结石治疗率(52.79%)显著更高(调整后的风险比为3.02;95%置信区间为2.30 - 3.98)。使用大量WLS的结石患者有较高的结石手术率。长期使用WLS对结石手术治疗没有预防作用。在本研究中,长期使用柠檬酸钾作为预防措施似乎未得到充分利用。