Vuolo Janet, Goffman Lisa
a Department of Speech, Language, and Hearing Sciences , Purdue University , West Lafayette , IN , USA.
Clin Linguist Phon. 2017;31(5):331-350. doi: 10.1080/02699206.2016.1261184. Epub 2016 Dec 14.
This exploratory treatment study used phonetic transcription and speech kinematics to examine changes in segmental and articulatory variability. Nine children, ages 4 to 8 years old, served as participants, including two with childhood apraxia of speech (CAS), five with speech sound disorder (SSD) and two who were typically developing. Children practised producing agent + action phrases in an imitation task (low linguistic load) and a retrieval task (high linguistic load) over five sessions. In the imitation task in session one, both participants with CAS showed high degrees of segmental and articulatory variability. After five sessions, imitation practice resulted in increased articulatory variability for five participants. Retrieval practice resulted in decreased articulatory variability in three participants with SSD. These results suggest that short-term speech production practice in rote imitation disrupts articulatory control in children with and without CAS. In contrast, tasks that require linguistic processing may scaffold learning for children with SSD but not CAS.
这项探索性治疗研究运用语音转录和言语运动学来检验节段性和发音变异性的变化。九名4至8岁的儿童作为参与者,其中包括两名患有儿童言语失用症(CAS)的儿童、五名患有语音障碍(SSD)的儿童以及两名发育正常的儿童。儿童在五个疗程中,于模仿任务(低语言负荷)和检索任务(高语言负荷)中练习说出施事+动作短语。在第一个疗程的模仿任务中,两名患有CAS的参与者均表现出高度的节段性和发音变异性。经过五个疗程后,模仿练习使五名参与者的发音变异性增加。检索练习使三名患有SSD的参与者的发音变异性降低。这些结果表明,死记硬背式模仿中的短期言语产生练习会扰乱患有和未患有CAS的儿童的发音控制。相比之下,需要语言处理的任务可能会为患有SSD但未患有CAS的儿童提供学习支架。