Caranzano L, Stephan M A, Herrmann F R, Benninger D H
Neurology Service, Department of Clinical Neurosciences, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Vaudois, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Faculté de Biologie et de Médecine, Doctoral School, Université de Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland; and.
J Neurophysiol. 2017 Mar 1;117(3):1052-1056. doi: 10.1152/jn.00381.2016. Epub 2016 Dec 14.
The paired-pulse (PP) transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) paradigms allow the exploration of the motor cortex physiology. The triple stimulation technique (TST) improves conventional TMS by reducing effects of desynchronization of motor neuron discharges allowing a precise evaluation of the corticospinal conduction. The objective of our study was to explore PP TMS paradigms combined with the TST to study whether the desynchronization contributes to these phenomena and whether the combined TMS-TST protocol could improve the consistency of responses. We investigated the PP paradigms of short intracortical inhibition (SICI) with 2 ms interstimulus interval (ISI) and of intracortical facilitation (ICF) with 10 ms ISI in 22 healthy subjects applying either conventional TMS alone or combined with the TST protocol. The results of the PP paradigms combined with the TST of SICI and ICF do not differ from those with conventional TMS. However, combining the PP paradigm with the TST reduces their variability. These results speak against a contribution of the desynchronization of motor neuron discharges to the PP paradigms of SICI and ICF. Combining the PP TMS paradigm with the TST may improve their consistency, but the interindividual variability remains such that it precludes their utility for clinical practice. Combining the triple stimulation technique with the paired-pulse stimulation paradigm improves the consistency of short intracortical inhibition and facilitation and could be useful in research, but the interindividual variability precludes their utility for clinical practice. Our findings do not suggest that desynchronization of descending discharges following transcranial magnetic stimulation contributes to short intracortical inhibition or intracortical facilitation.
配对脉冲(PP)经颅磁刺激(TMS)范式有助于探索运动皮质生理学。三重刺激技术(TST)通过减少运动神经元放电去同步化的影响改进了传统TMS,从而能够精确评估皮质脊髓传导。我们研究的目的是探索将PP TMS范式与TST相结合,以研究去同步化是否促成了这些现象,以及联合TMS-TST方案是否能提高反应的一致性。我们在22名健康受试者中,采用单独的传统TMS或联合TST方案,研究了刺激间隔(ISI)为2 ms的短皮质内抑制(SICI)和ISI为10 ms的皮质内易化(ICF)的PP范式。SICI和ICF的PP范式与TST联合的结果与传统TMS的结果并无差异。然而,将PP范式与TST相结合可降低其变异性。这些结果表明,运动神经元放电的去同步化对SICI和ICF的PP范式并无贡献。将PP TMS范式与TST相结合可能会提高其一致性,但个体间变异性仍然存在,这使得它们无法用于临床实践。将三重刺激技术与配对脉冲刺激范式相结合可提高短皮质内抑制和易化的一致性,在研究中可能有用,但个体间变异性使其无法用于临床实践。我们的研究结果并不表明经颅磁刺激后下行放电的去同步化会促成短皮质内抑制或皮质内易化。