Gelman Amanda, Rosenfeld Elian A, Nikolajski Cara, Freedman Lori R, Steinberg Julia R, Borrero Sonya
Resident in internal medicine, University of Colorado, Aurora.
Postdoctoral fellow of women's health, VA Pittsburgh Healthcare System.
Perspect Sex Reprod Health. 2017 Mar;49(1):29-36. doi: 10.1363/psrh.12014. Epub 2016 Dec 16.
Abortion stigma may cause psychological distress in women who are considering having an abortion or have had one. This phenomenon has been relatively underexplored in low-income women, who may already be at an increased risk for poor abortion-related outcomes because of difficulties accessing timely and safe abortion services.
A qualitative study conducted between 2010 and 2013 used semistructured interviews to explore pregnancy intentions among low-income women recruited from six reproductive health clinics in Western Pennsylvania. Transcripts from interviews with 19 participants who were planning to terminate a pregnancy or had had an abortion in the last two weeks were examined through content analysis to identify the range of attitudes they encountered that could contribute to or reflect abortion stigma, the sources of these attitudes and women's responses to them.
Women commonly reported that partners, family members and they themselves held antiabortion attitudes. Such attitudes communicated that abortion is morally reprehensible, a rejection of motherhood, rare and thus potentially deviant, detrimental to future fertility and an irresponsible choice. Women reacted to external and internal negative attitudes by distinguishing themselves from other women who obtain abortions, experiencing negative emotions, and concealing or delaying their abortions.
Women's reactions to antiabortion attitudes may perpetuate abortion stigma. Further research is needed to inform interventions to address abortion stigma and improve women's abortion experiences.
流产污名化可能会给正在考虑流产或已经流产的女性带来心理困扰。在低收入女性中,这一现象相对较少受到关注,由于难以获得及时、安全的流产服务,她们可能已经面临与流产相关的不良后果风险增加的问题。
2010年至2013年进行的一项定性研究,采用半结构化访谈,探讨从宾夕法尼亚西部六家生殖健康诊所招募的低收入女性的怀孕意向。通过对19名计划终止妊娠或在过去两周内已流产的参与者的访谈记录进行内容分析,以确定她们所遇到的可能导致或反映流产污名化的态度范围、这些态度的来源以及女性对这些态度的反应。
女性普遍报告称,伴侣、家庭成员以及她们自己持有反堕胎态度。这些态度表明流产在道德上应受谴责,是对母性的拒绝,罕见且因此可能是异常的,对未来生育有害,是一种不负责任的选择。女性通过将自己与其他流产女性区分开来、体验负面情绪以及隐瞒或推迟流产来应对外部和内部的负面态度。
女性对反堕胎态度的反应可能会使流产污名化持续存在。需要进一步开展研究,为消除流产污名化和改善女性流产经历的干预措施提供依据。