Burdwan Medical College, West Bengal, India.
Department of Pediatrics, Command Hospital, Pune, India.
Acta Paediatr. 2017 Mar;106(3):411-415. doi: 10.1111/apa.13716. Epub 2017 Jan 17.
Research on alternative female Kangaroo care (KC) has been hampered by high maternal refusal rates. We assessed the efficacy of Kangaroo mother care (KMC), alternative KC provided by other postpartum mothers and swaddling for postprocedural pain relief in preterm babies.
The study was carried out in a tertiary armed forces hospital, where mothers did not have support from other female relatives and other postpartum mothers agreed to act as alternative female KC providers. We exposed 51 stable preterm neonates, with a gestational age of 30-36 weeks, to KMC, alternative female KC and swaddling for 30 minutes before heel lancing. The outcome measures included the Preterm Infant Pain Profile (PIPP) scores at 30 seconds and the time taken for the heart rate to return to baseline.
The mean PIPP scores were lower with KMC (10.59) and alternative female KC (11.24) than swaddling (12.96) and heart rate normalisation took 111, 117 and 149 seconds respectively. The p values were <0.001 for individual groups and outcomes. KMC fared better than alternative female KC for both pain (p = 0.045) and heart rate (p = 0.013).
Providing KMC and alternative female KC before heel lancing resulted in better pain relief than swaddling.
替代女性袋鼠式护理(KC)的研究受到高拒绝率的阻碍。我们评估了袋鼠式母亲护理(KMC)、由其他产后母亲提供的替代 KC 和襁褓对早产儿术后疼痛缓解的效果。
该研究在一家三级武装部队医院进行,在那里,母亲没有得到其他女性亲属的支持,并且其他产后母亲同意充当替代女性 KC 提供者。我们让 51 名稳定的早产儿在足跟采血前接受 30 分钟的 KMC、替代女性 KC 和襁褓。结果测量包括足跟采血前 30 秒的早产儿疼痛量表(PIPP)评分和心率恢复到基线所需的时间。
KMC(10.59)和替代女性 KC(11.24)的 PIPP 评分均低于襁褓(12.96),而心率恢复正常分别需要 111、117 和 149 秒。各个组和结果的 p 值均<0.001。KMC 在疼痛(p = 0.045)和心率(p = 0.013)方面均优于替代女性 KC。
足跟采血前提供 KMC 和替代女性 KC 可比襁褓更有效地缓解疼痛。