Sun Xinyao, Byrns Simon, Cheng Irene, Zheng Bin, Basu Anup
Multimedia Research Center, Department of Computing Science, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada.
Surgical Simulation Research Lab, Department of Surgery, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB, Canada.
J Med Syst. 2017 Feb;41(2):24. doi: 10.1007/s10916-016-0665-4. Epub 2016 Dec 20.
We introduce a smart sensor-based motion detection technique for objective measurement and assessment of surgical dexterity among users at different experience levels. The goal is to allow trainees to evaluate their performance based on a reference model shared through communication technology, e.g., the Internet, without the physical presence of an evaluating surgeon. While in the current implementation we used a Leap Motion Controller to obtain motion data for analysis, our technique can be applied to motion data captured by other smart sensors, e.g., OptiTrack. To differentiate motions captured from different participants, measurement and assessment in our approach are achieved using two strategies: (1) low level descriptive statistical analysis, and (2) Hidden Markov Model (HMM) classification. Based on our surgical knot tying task experiment, we can conclude that finger motions generated from users with different surgical dexterity, e.g., expert and novice performers, display differences in path length, number of movements and task completion time. In order to validate the discriminatory ability of HMM for classifying different movement patterns, a non-surgical task was included in our analysis. Experimental results demonstrate that our approach had 100 % accuracy in discriminating between expert and novice performances. Our proposed motion analysis technique applied to open surgical procedures is a promising step towards the development of objective computer-assisted assessment and training systems.
我们介绍一种基于智能传感器的运动检测技术,用于客观测量和评估不同经验水平用户的手术灵巧性。目标是让受训人员能够根据通过通信技术(如互联网)共享的参考模型来评估自己的表现,而无需评估外科医生亲自在场。虽然在当前实现中我们使用了Leap Motion控制器来获取运动数据进行分析,但我们的技术可应用于其他智能传感器(如OptiTrack)捕获的运动数据。为了区分不同参与者捕获的运动,我们的方法中的测量和评估使用两种策略来实现:(1)低级描述性统计分析,以及(2)隐马尔可夫模型(HMM)分类。基于我们的手术打结任务实验,我们可以得出结论,具有不同手术灵巧性的用户(如专家和新手执行者)产生的手指运动在路径长度、运动次数和任务完成时间方面存在差异。为了验证HMM对不同运动模式分类的辨别能力,我们在分析中纳入了一项非手术任务。实验结果表明,我们的方法在区分专家和新手表现方面具有100%的准确率。我们提出的应用于开放手术程序的运动分析技术是朝着开发客观的计算机辅助评估和训练系统迈出的有希望的一步。